| Reading time: 3 minutes
Freiburg lodges a protest against the rating of the defeat against FC Bayern, as the club sees its legal turn. The chances of success of the appeal are slim. Munich coach Julian Nagelsmann clearly criticized Freiburg’s move.
KAum chances of success or a quick decision, but full criticism from Bayern Munich coach Julian Nagelsmann. The mistake made by the record champions and the protest by the defeated SC Freiburg that followed on Monday evening remains the topic of discussion in the Bundesliga and could make the race for qualification for the Champions League and Europa League even more exciting. Because if Freiburg were legally successful, the teams behind the hasty leader Bavaria would move closer together again.
“I don’t know if you can pat yourself on the back if you should play internationally because of three points that you didn’t actually win in sporting terms. I wouldn’t be so happy there. That’s why I would have clearly communicated to the club that we would not appeal,” said Nagelsmann. “Personally, I wouldn’t have done it because I think you take advantage of a third party’s mistake to maybe get points because the pressure from the fans or the sponsors is so great.”
Jurisdiction pro Freiburg would have the greatest consequences for Nagelsmann’s ex-club RB Leipzig. Although the Saxons would still be in fourth place ahead of the Breisgauers, the lead of three points gained through the win at Borussia Dortmund would be gone. TSG 1899 Hoffenheim, currently one point behind Freiburg, would then have to catch up four points. “It is not for us to comment on the issue. The case is in the hands of the independent sports courts, which must decide this case,” said a club spokesman for Hoffenheim on Tuesday. Leipzig did not want to comment on request.
The transfer requested by FC Bayern was completely legal
You should be left with the clubs concerned anyway. Because the chances of success of the objection against the rating of 1: 4 estimate experts familiar with the procedure as extremely low. The focus of the fault in the change error of Munich lies with the referees, for which the Bundesliga club cannot be punished. The change requested by Munich was completely legal. In addition, nothing decisive happened.
Freiburg had lodged a protest against the rating on Monday evening, as it was formally in the active role of having the processes legally checked. Shortly before the end, Bayern were 3-1 up for a few seconds with twelve players before referee Christian Dingert stopped the game. A decision does not necessarily have to be made before the next match day, as the time frame depends on how involved the parties are in the process.
The case is now the responsibility of the sports court of the German Football Association. The legal justification of SC Freiburg is now available there. The current procedure now applies, said a spokesman for the association on Tuesday.
In German football, there were a few substitution errors that successfully led to game re-evaluations. For example, on April 15, 1995, Bayern Munich coach Giovanni Trapattoni switched on the later international Dietmar Hamann as the fourth contract amateur at Eintracht Frankfurt, but only three were allowed. Bayern’s 5-2 was annulled and the game went 2-0 to Frankfurt.
The last serious faux pas happened to VfL Wolfsburg in the 2021/2022 season. In the cup first round game on August 8, 2021 at Preußen Münster under the direction of referee Dingert, coach Mark van Bommel substituted six players instead of the five allowed. Lower Saxony won 3-1 after extra time, but Münster successfully appealed and advanced to the next round after beating Prussia 2-0.