Justin Gaethje Rules Out Ilia Topuria Rematch: “No Right to a Rematch After Abandoning Twice”

Gaethje’s comments, made during a recent appearance on Joe Rogan Experience, mark the first time he has publicly dismissed the possibility of a rematch with Topuria, who finished his 18-fight undefeated streak when the American won the UFC lightweight title at the South Lawn of the White House on July 20, 2024.

According to Gaethje, Topuria’s performance—particularly his twice-stopped condition and eventual retirement from the fight before the fifth round—justifies the decision. “He abandoned. Abandoned twice. I stopped him twice,” Gaethje said. “What more do I have to do?”

Topuria, who is recovering from facial injuries sustained in the fight, now faces an uncertain path back to the octagon without a clear opponent. Gaethje’s remarks effectively reorder the lightweight division’s hierarchy, with Pimblett emerging as the next logical challenger.

Why Gaethje Closed the Door: The Fight That Changed Everything

The UFC lightweight title fight between Gaethje and Topuria at UFC Freedom 250 was a turning point for both fighters. Gaethje, who had previously lost to Topuria in their 2022 UFC Fight Night encounter, returned to claim the undisputed lightweight championship in a dominant performance.

According to official UFC fight stats, Gaethje opened the fight with a powerful right hand that dropped Topuria early in the first round. He then proceeded to land a flurry of uppercuts and knees to Topuria’s face, causing significant swelling and a visible eye injury. By the fourth round, Topuria’s corner threw in the towel, ending the fight and Topuria’s undefeated streak.

“He abandoned. Abandoned twice. I stopped him twice. What more do I have to do?”

— Justin Gaethje, on Joe Rogan Experience (July 2024)

Gaethje’s frustration was palpable in his remarks. The fight had been a one-sided affair, with Topuria struggling to mount any significant offense. The stoppage came as a surprise to many, given Topuria’s reputation as a grappling specialist who had defeated multiple champions, including Alexander Volkanovski, Max Holloway, and Charles Oliveira.

While Gaethje’s decision to rule out a rematch may seem harsh, it aligns with UFC policy, which typically requires fighters to earn a rematch through performance rather than simply requesting one. Topuria’s stoppage loss—particularly the twice-stopped condition—weighs heavily in Gaethje’s decision.

Paddy Pimblett Emerges as Topuria’s Next Challenge

With a rematch off the table, Gaethje has already signaled who he believes should be Topuria’s next opponent: Paddy Pimblett. The British fighter, known for his aggressive striking and recent rise in the UFC rankings, has a personal history with Topuria.

In 2022, Pimblett and Topuria clashed outside the octagon after Topuria’s victory over Gaethje at UFC 278. Pimblett publicly called Topuria a “coward” for allegedly avoiding a post-fight confrontation, a remark that fueled their rivalry. The UFC has since hinted at a potential matchup between the two, which Gaethje’s comments now appear to accelerate.

“His next challenge can’t be me,” Gaethje told Rogan. “He needs to fight Paddy Pimblett or someone like that.”

Pimblett, who defeated Islam Makhachev at UFC 298 in February 2024, has been on a tear in the lightweight division. His aggressive style and recent momentum make him a natural next step for Topuria, who will need to prove he can compete at the highest level again.

Gaethje at 37: A Champion With No Exit Strategy

At 37 years old, Gaethje has achieved what many fighters only dream of: a UFC title. But unlike some champions who retire after their first belt win, Gaethje has made it clear he has no plans to slow down.

“Right now, I’m planning on coming back and fighting. There’s nothing natural in me that makes me feel like it’s over.”

— Justin Gaethje, on Joe Rogan Experience (July 2024)

Gaethje’s statement reflects his long-standing reputation as a fighter who thrives under pressure. His victory over Topuria was his third UFC title win, solidifying his legacy as one of the most resilient competitors in MMA history. With no clear successor in the lightweight division, Gaethje’s decision to continue competing could further extend his dominance.

Topuria, meanwhile, faces a more uncertain future. His recovery from the facial injuries sustained in the fight will be critical, as will his ability to regain form. Without a rematch with Gaethje, his path back to the top will depend on his performance against Pimblett or another top contender.

How This Reshapes the UFC Lightweight Division

Gaethje’s decision to rule out a rematch with Topuria and redirect him toward Pimblett has significant implications for the UFC lightweight division:

• Pimblett’s rise: A potential matchup between Pimblett and Topuria would be a high-profile bout, given their history and the current state of the division. Pimblett’s recent wins have positioned him as a legitimate title contender.
• Topuria’s path forward: Without a rematch, Topuria must prove he can compete at the highest level again. His fight against Pimblett would serve as a litmus test for his recovery and readiness.
• Gaethje’s dominance: By closing the door on Topuria and signaling his intention to continue competing, Gaethje reinforces his status as the undisputed lightweight champion. His decision also removes potential distractions, allowing him to focus on defending his title.
• UFC’s strategic move: The promotion benefits from this narrative, as it creates clear storylines for future events. A Pimblett vs. Topuria fight would be a major draw, while Gaethje’s continued presence ensures ongoing title defense opportunities.

What This Means for Fighters, Fans, and the UFC

What Happens Next?

The UFC has not yet officially announced any fights, but the stage is set for several key developments:

• Topuria’s recovery: His timeline for returning to competition will depend on the severity of his facial injuries. If he is cleared quickly, a fight with Pimblett could materialize in late 2024 or early 2025.
• Pimblett’s next opponent: If Topuria is not ready, Pimblett may face another challenger, such as Brad Riddell or Rafael Fiziev, before a potential rematch with Topuria.
• Gaethje’s title defense: The champion will likely look to defend his belt soon, with potential opponents including Dustin Poirier, Michael Chandler, or another rising contender.
• UFC event planning: A Pimblett vs. Topuria fight would be a major draw, potentially headlining a prime-time event in the coming months.

The UFC will likely hold a press conference or official announcement in the coming weeks to clarify the next steps for both Topuria and Pimblett. Fans can expect updates on fight dates, venues, and potential title defense bouts for Gaethje.

What Do You Think?

Does Gaethje’s decision to rule out a rematch with Topuria make sense? Who should be Topuria’s next opponent? Share your thoughts in the comments below.

For the latest updates on UFC lightweight division news, follow Archysport and stay tuned for official announcements from the UFC.