The St. Louis Cardinals face a roster challenge heading into 2027, as they currently carry five high-level catching options on their organizational depth chart. With four backstops already on the 40-man roster and a top-tier prospect waiting in the wings, the team must decide which players will define the future of the position.
Bernal leads the competition for the starting role
The Panamanian catcher emerged as a standout candidate during a brief September call-up in 2026. After hitting 16 home runs in 101 games for Triple-A Memphis, he posted an .807 OPS over 102 plate appearances in the major leagues. Chaim Bloom, the team’s president of baseball operations, noted the immediate impact the young player made on the coaching staff and veteran teammates.
“Ese fue prácticamente el mayor provecho que he visto en mi carrera por parte de un jugador en una breve estadía de septiembre,” Bloom said. Given his defensive pedigree and late-season performance, he remains the frontrunner to secure the starting job on Opening Day.
Crooks balances power with major league adjustment
After a productive stint in Triple-A where he maintained a .300 batting average and a 1.006 OPS, the organization remains invested in the potential of the young catcher. His transition to the major leagues in 2026 proved difficult, as he batted .179 with a .591 OPS across limited appearances.
The front office faces a decision regarding whether he should serve as the primary backup in St. Louis or continue his development as an everyday starter in Memphis. His future may depend on whether the team opts to retain him or use the league-wide demand for catching depth to facilitate a trade.
Herrera seeks to regain form
Ivan Herrera experienced a challenging 2026 campaign, as his power numbers remained stagnant while his on-base percentage dipped compared to previous seasons. Although he earned an All-Star selection following a strong first half, his production slowed during the final 86 games of the year.
The team used him primarily as a designated hitter rather than behind the plate, and he will need to show offensive improvement in 2027 to justify a spot on the roster. With a crowded depth chart, the club may explore trade options for the right-handed hitter if they determine he cannot consistently contribute at the major league level.
Pagés provides defensive stability
Widely recognized by his teammates for his rapport with the pitching staff and his defensive instincts, Pedro Pagés remains one of the most respected figures in the clubhouse. However, his offensive output in 2026, which included a .275 on-base percentage and four home runs, led to a reduction in his playing time.
While his value behind the plate remains clear, he currently occupies the most vulnerable position on the roster. The organization has expressed a long-term interest in his potential as a coach, though his immediate future as a player depends on his ability to provide more consistency at the plate.
Rodríguez headlines the next wave of talent
Widely considered the top catching prospect in the organization, the 19-year-old Dominican standout has excelled at every level of the minor leagues. He recorded an .999 OPS at Double-A Springfield in 2026, proving that his offensive ceiling is exceptionally high.
While he has spent time at first and third base to increase his versatility, the team intends to keep him at catcher for the time being. As he approaches his 20th birthday on January 4, his rapid development suggests he could challenge for a major league role sooner than anticipated, further complicating the team’s long-term strategy behind the plate.
Related reading