Robot umpire appeals for checked swings lowered whiff rates on breaking and offspeed pitches during testing in the Triple-A Pacific Coast League this year, according to reports from Yahoo Sports.
Pitchers continue throwing harder across baseball, forcing hitters into difficult battles just to make contact. Minor league data indicates that automated reviews could ease that pressure.
Whiff rates dropped by 2.6 percentage points on curveballs, sliders, sweepers, and knuckleballs from May 5 through the end of the season when batters could challenge checked swings using MLB’s Automated Ball-Strike Challenge System. Changeups, splitters, and screwballs saw an even larger drop of 3.6 percentage points.
“I think I like it,” said Arizona Diamondbacks general manager Mike Hazen. “I don’t think I like the art of calling a check swing. I think that seems to be an area of frustration for players.”
Two Decades of Rising Strikeouts
Advanced pitcher development has pushed strikeout rates upward over the last twenty years. Figures climbed from 16.4% of plate appearances in 2006 to 23.9% last season.
Rates reached a record 27% in 2022 before dropping slightly after the pitch clock arrived in 2023. Strikeout rates remained nearly identical in 2025 and ’26 despite the implementation of ABS.

Official Baseball Rules do not clearly define a checked swing, stating only that a strike is a legal pitch struck at by the batter and missed. The ABS experiment applied a strict threshold, counting a swing when the maximum angle between the bat head and handle exceeded 45 degrees.
“Maybe there’s a slight modification to it,” said Los Angeles Dodgers general manager Brandon Gomes, according to Yahoo Sports, noting that the current angle can make full-looking swings appear like checked swings.
Minor League Testing Timeline
Testing for checked-swing challenges began in the Arizona Fall League in 2024 before expanding to the Class A Florida State League in 2025.
During PCL games featuring the challenge system, batters appealed 0.25 calls per game with a 55.5% overturn rate. Overall whiff rates in those games declined from 25.3% to 24.1%.
In the Triple-A International League, where umpires used the 45-degree rule without ABS appeals, the whiff rate dipped slightly from 23% in 2025 to 22.9%.
Fastball whiff rates in the PCL were 19.3% from May 5 onward, down slightly from 19.4% during the same period last year. Non-fastball pitches declined because batters are fooled more frequently on breaking and offspeed deliveries.
Major League Adoption Faces Delays Until 2028
Baseball Commissioner Rob Manfred has said that any major league adoption of ABS for checked swings will not happen until 2028 at the earliest.
“We’ve made a lot of changes in the last five years and it’s time to stabilize a little bit, in my opinion,” said New York Yankees pitcher Gerrit Cole, the 2023 AL Cy Young Award winner. “This situation right now with the ABS has gone really, really well, so let’s not mess a good thing up.”
Rule changes regarding half swings date back decades, with managers and catchers permitted since 1976 to request help from base umpires only when the plate umpire calls a pitch a ball.
Any potential major league implementation remains dependent on further minor league data and continued evaluation by league officials ahead of the 2028 season.
Keep reading