Pablo Mouche vs. Carlo Villanueva: Former Colo Colo Teammates Clash Over 2019 Tunnel Fight and Relegation Battle

Former Colo forward Pablo Mouche and midfielder Carlo Villanueva have engaged in a public dispute this week, revisiting tensions from their time together at the club during the 2019 and 2020 seasons, according to Bolavip Chile.

The conflict surfaced after Mouche, in a conversation with YouTuber Joaco Santos, described a heated locker room confrontation that nearly escalated into physical violence during a match against Huachipato, according to AS Chile. The interview was published on the YouTube channel Sistema Joaco Santos.

Confrontation in the Monumental tunnel

The disagreement, which occurred in October 2019, began on the pitch before spilling into the tunnel at halftime, according to reporting by TVN. Mouche, who played for the Argentine side Boca Juniors, claimed the conflict arose after he attempted to correct the younger player’s decisions on the field. “I should have hit him,” Mouche said in the interview.

He described Villanueva as mentally weak for the pressure of the first team, adding that he warned him: “Finish the match and I will break your head.” Mouche said Villanueva was considered the successor to Jorge Valdivia, who was the starter and injured at the time. He added that Villanueva ignored him when he spoke to him nicely at first, and then made a gesture that provoked the threat.

Mouche recounted that Villanueva approached him in the tunnel after the first half, allegedly leading to a situation where teammates had to intervene to prevent a physical fight. En Cancha reported that the Argentine accused the midfielder of ignoring his instructions and making disrespectful gestures during the game.

Mouche said that when Villanueva touched him in the tunnel, he told him to talk inside, but Villanueva kept shouting, so he threatened to rip his head off, and teammates separated them.

Pablo Mouche vs. Carlo Villanueva: Former Colo Colo Teammates Clash Over 2019 Tunnel Fight and Relegation Battle
Photo: AS Chile

Villanueva responds on social media

Villanueva, who currently plays for Unión La Calera, utilized Instagram to address the claims. The midfielder directed a sharp retort toward his former teammate, questioning Mouche’s own commitment during the club’s most difficult period.

“Now that you like to talk, also tell us why you didn’t play when we were fighting relegation,” Villanueva wrote in a story, accompanied by laughing emojis, according to BioBioChile. He tagged Mouche in the post.

This response references the 2020 season, when Colo narrowly avoided relegation to Primera B. The club ultimately secured its place in the top flight by defeating Universidad de Concepción in a decisive match in Talca in February 2021, a game in which Mouche did not participate.

Bolavip Chile reported that the exchange highlights the lingering internal frictions from that era of the club’s history. Mouche had been at the center of controversy for his absence in that match against Universidad de Concepción, which ended with an Alba victory and the team’s permanence in the First Division.

Support from Martín Rodríguez

The dispute gained further attention when Martín Rodríguez, currently a player for Erzurumspor FK in Turkey, publicly backed Villanueva. Rodríguez, who joined Colo the year following the initial incident, commented on the Instagram post, stating, “That I like,” as noted by Bolavip Chile.

While Rodríguez was not part of the 2019 squad, his intervention added visibility to the public disagreement between the two former teammates. Rodríguez arrived the following year and became very close with Villanueva.

History of the conflict

The following timeline details the development of the tensions between the players:

The MATERIAL is about the Argentine footballer Pablo Nicolás Mouche (born 1987) who plays for Barracas Central and debuted for the national team in 2011. The ARTICLE is about a Pablo Mouche who played for Colo (Colo-Colo) in 2019–2020, was a former Boca Juniors player, and did not play in the 2021 relegation playoff.

The MATERIAL does not mention Colo-Colo, the 2019–2020 seasons, the Huachipato match, the tunnel confrontation, or the 2021 relegation playoff. It only covers his career up to 2011 (Boca Juniors, loan to Arsenal de Sarandí, West Ham United loan talks). Since the MATERIAL is about another person of the same name and gives nothing new about the Pablo Mouche in the article, the correct response is NONE.

Pablo Mouche vs. Carlo Villanueva: Former Colo Colo Teammates Clash Over 2019 Tunnel Fight and Relegation Battle
Photo: En Cancha
  • October 2019: Mouche and Villanueva engage in a heated dispute during and after a match against Huachipato.
  • 2020: Colo faces a campaign unlike any before, fighting to avoid relegation all season.
  • February 2021: The club avoids relegation after winning a playoff match against Universidad de Concepción.
  • Pablo Mouche recently detailed a 2019 locker room incident with Carlo Villanueva, prompting a direct social media response from Villanueva.

The exchange remains a point of discussion in Chilean football circles, as both players continue their professional careers with different clubs.

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archysport.