Indiana fell five spots to ninth in the College Football Playoff rankings during its bye week.
Indiana head coach Curt Cignetti criticized the committee for inconsistent treatment based on brand names, stadiums, and marketing rather than on-field performance. “I get tired of the narrative sometimes,” Cignetti said, according to Fox News.
“Well, quality win because Joe Smith was out there, and that team hasn’t won since. But it was a quality win at the time. Bad losses don’t count. Hey, it’s all decided on the field. Good for hype. I’m sure it gets a lot of views and clicks,” Cignetti said, according to Fox News.
Committee chair Hunter Yurachek said Indiana taking a bye week during a week with seven matchups between ranked teams hurt the program. Yurachek also said that all Big Ten opponents Indiana had played up to that point had lost, which affected their strength of schedule evaluation. Yurachek added that Indiana’s quarterback and offense were discussed, noting the team has won primarily through defense.
“The Big Ten opponents that Indiana has played to date have all lost, and that’s impacted their strength-of-schedule rank,” Yurachek said, according to Fox News.
Fox News reported that excluding Saturday’s loss to Vanderbilt, five of the teams Alabama defeated had lost on that same day, with four of those losses occurring at home. Those opponents combined for a 27-23 record, with eight victories coming against Kent State, Towson, Louisiana-Monroe, Youngstown State, Louisiana Tech, McNeese State, Missouri State, and The Citadel.
Against Vanderbilt’s defense—which was ranked 110th in the FBS in points allowed—Alabama averaged 4.5 yards per play, according to Fox News. Excluding three plays of 20 yards or more, Alabama gained 227 yards on 65 plays, averaging 3.49 yards per play. A third-quarter touchdown drive covered 12 yards following a long kickoff return.
Fox News said that these criticisms do not mean Alabama lacks playoff qualifications, as the team ranks in the top five to 10 nationally in underlying performance and predictive metrics.
Alabama reached the 12-team playoff last season despite a lopsided loss in the SEC Championship Game and two losses to top-10 opponents Georgia and Tennessee, while Notre Dame was said to not deserve to advance after losing to Miami and Texas A&M.
Tuesday’s ranking release will show whether the committee lowers Alabama’s position following weekend results or maintains its stance on SEC teams.
Related reading