Nearly 44 years after poisoned capsules killed seven people in the Chicago area, investigators have uncovered personal belongings and Chicago street maps belonging to a former chemist who died by suicide in Idaho, FAZ reported.
Seven deaths and millions of recalled bottles
The tragedy began in late September 1982 when 12-year-old Mary Kellerman woke up with a sore throat in Elk Grove Village, a Chicago suburb, and died hours after taking an over-the-counter pain reliever, according to FAZ. Hours later, postal worker Adam Janus collapsed in Arlington Heights.
When his brother Stanley and sister-in-law Theresa gathered at his home to mourn, they took capsules from the same bottle of Tylenol found in the victim’s medicine cabinet. Stanley Janus died shortly afterward, and his wife passed away two days later, FAZ reported.
Over the following days, three more sudden fatalities struck the Chicago metropolitan area. Alongside Kellerman and the three members of the Janus family, victims Mary McFarland, Paula Prince, and Mary Weiner had each ingested a Tylenol capsule shortly before dying, FAZ reported. As nationwide panic set in, pharmaceutical giant Johnson & Johnson pulled more than 30 million bottles from store shelves, FAZ reported.
Investigators determined that the bottles had been laced with cyanide, leading authorities to conclude that an unknown perpetrator stole the boxes from grocery and drugstore shelves, spiked the pills with the toxic white powder, and returned them to circulation without leaving a clear motive, FAZ reported.
The unknown wanderer in Idaho
Weeks after the Chicago killings, members of the Sacred Heart Catholic community in Boise, Idaho, discovered an unidentified dead man beneath a church pew, FAZ reported. Blood tests revealed he died from a small dose of cyanide, while his pockets contained roughly 2,000 dollars and a typed note requesting a burial in the event of his death, FAZ reported.
Decades later, Ada County Sheriff’s Office cold case investigator Tim Cooper reviewed the belongings of the deceased man, according to FAZ. Cooper spotted an engraved address on one of roughly 30 keys, leading investigators to a former Jacksonville resident named Mathew Francis Betkouski, who had disappeared and was declared dead in 1989, FAZ reported.
“We contacted his brother in Los Angeles and asked him for a DNA sample, which we compared with genetic material we found on the deceased’s wallet,” Cooper told Boise State Public Radio News.
A troubled past and cyanide fantasies
Betkouski hailed from a wealthy Southern California family and worked as a chemist for various firms after completing his studies and earning a doctorate, FAZ reported. A 1974 accident and subsequent brain injury drastically altered his personality, prompting paranoia, talking to himself, and psychiatric treatment, according to FAZ.
In early 1982, authorities arrested the chemist in Las Cruces, New Mexico, after he grew aggressive when staff refused to sell him capsules intended for an alleged experiment, FAZ reported.
Former colleagues from his college days in Florida recalled Betkouski frequently talking about committing the “perfect crime” using cyanide poisoning as an undetectable method of murder, FAZ reported. Cooper discovered a vial of white powder inside a desk preserved by Betkouski’s brother in Los Angeles, indicating the chemist may have manufactured the substance himself, FAZ reported.
“However, it was sodium cyanide and not potassium cyanide like in the Chicago murder series,” Cooper told NBC, adding that the desk also contained Chicago street maps and photographs of the chemist in the Windy City from 1981. “We are not listing Dr. Betkouski as a suspect for now because we do not know if he was also in Chicago in late September 1982,” Cooper told FAZ.
Johnson & Johnson, founded in 1886 by three brothers in New Brunswick, New Jersey, with 14 employees, pioneered the world’s first sterile surgical dressings and published the first mass-distributed guide to antiseptic wound treatment. By 1888 the company had also introduced the first commercial first aid kits, originally designed for railroad workers far from medical care.
Ongoing forensic debates
Police departments in Chicago alongside federal investigators confirmed they are continuing their active inquiries into the historic Tylenol murders. “Many American forensic scientists assume that the dead man from Boise is at least a suspect in the case of the Tylenol murders,” forensic psychiatrist Park Dietz told FAZ. “Some forensic scientists are even convinced that the ‘Unknown Wanderer’ is the murderer.”