Magnus Carlsen, the world’s top-ranked chess player since 2011, has faced mounting scrutiny at the Total Chess World Championship in Budapest, Hungary, after forfeiting multiple games to protect his Elo rating.
The Norwegian grandmaster, who has held the number one spot for over a decade, opted out of two “Fast Classic” matches against Kazakhstan’s Bibisara Assaubayeva, a decision that has sparked debate over tournament sportsmanship and professional ethics.
The Total Chess event is designed as a “triathlon” of chess, requiring participants to compete across three distinct time formats: 45 minutes for classic, 15 minutes for rapid, and 3 minutes for blitz. According to Il Post, Carlsen—who has long expressed boredom with traditional long-format games—struggled to maintain his usual dominance during the tournament’s group stages.
While he secured a victory against Assaubayeva in their overall knockout matchup with a score of 11.5–8.5, as reported by DAZN, his choice to skip the final classic-format games allowed him to avoid the potential rating hit that a loss to a lower-rated opponent would incur. In the tournament’s group phase, the 35-year-old Carlsen failed to win any of his ten Fast Classic matches.
Magnus Carlsen to TV2 on forfeiting his Fast classic game against Bibisara Assaubayeva at the Total Chess World Championship Knockouts: "There will be no classical game as I understood, the match is over. The only consequence of not showing up is that you will lose a totally… pic.twitter.com/ouKuUfms1D”
Tournament Pilot Uses Knockout Brackets for Final Rankings
The competition, which features 24 players divided into four groups of six, functions as a pilot for a championship circuit planned for 2027. Following the initial stages, participants moved into “Knockout Brackets” to determine final placements from 1st through 24th. In his matchup against Assaubayeva, Carlsen held a 10–2 lead after the rapid and blitz rounds, rendering the final classic game mathematically inconsequential to his progression.
Despite his stature, the Norwegian is currently competing for a 17th-place finish against Russian player Vladislav Artemiev. Other top players have similarly struggled; 21-year-old Indian grandmaster Rameshbabu Praggnanandhaa, known as Pragg, lost three classic-format games without securing a single victory.
Hans Niemann, a fellow competitor at the Budapest event, publicly questioned the fairness of the tournament rules. “It is incredibly disappointing to see that a player continues to receive preferential treatment,” Niemann wrote on X, as cited by DAZN.
“All rules must be applied the same way, regardless of the player. Period.” Niemann also noted previous controversies involving Carlsen, including a dispute regarding the dress code at the 2024 World Rapid Chess Championship, according to DAZN.

The controversy surrounding the forfeits has widened as other players have followed suit. OA Sport reported that both Abhimanyu Mishra and Richard Rapport also declined to play their respective Fast Classic matches once their overall results were mathematically determined. Emil Sutovsky, executive director of the International Chess Federation (FIDE), criticized the trend, stating that “it is difficult to comment on such mean and unsportsmanlike behavior,” according to Il Post.
Despite the criticism, Carlsen defended his actions in an interview with Norwegian broadcaster TV 2. He maintained that since the result of the day’s competition had already been decided through the rapid and blitz rounds, there was no practical reason to contest the classic games.
Carlsen, who currently faces pressure from Fabiano Caruana in the world rankings, remains at risk of falling below the 2,800 Elo threshold, a milestone he has maintained for 17 years. In the virtual rankings, Caruana has closed the gap to just 7 points, standing at 2801.2 compared to Carlsen’s 2794.2, pending the conclusion of his match against Alireza Firouzja.
Born in 1990, Magnus Carlsen established himself as a prodigy by earning the grandmaster title at age 13. His career is marked by unprecedented consistency and statistical milestones, including a peak Elo rating of 2882—the highest achieved since the rating system was adopted in 1970—and a record-breaking streak of 125 unbeaten games at the elite classical level.
Beyond his individual tournament successes, he became the first player to simultaneously hold the World Chess Championship, World Rapid Championship, and World Blitz Championship titles, a feat he accomplished multiple times throughout his career.
Hard to comment on such a pathetic unsporsmanlike conduct.
The Total Chess tournament continues to serve as an experimental pilot with semifinals concluding November 18 and finals scheduled for November 19 and 20. While the broader chess world turns its attention to the upcoming World Championship match in Geneva, Switzerland, where Gukesh Dommaraju and Javokhir Sindarov are scheduled to compete from November 24 to December 12, 2026, the current events in Budapest highlight the ongoing tensions surrounding format changes in professional chess.
More on Total Chess World Championship
Having already clinched the match 11.5–0.5, Magnus forfeits his Fast Classic game against Bibisara. #TotalChess pic.twitter.com/jIiM3n9Y2x
"Forfeiting a game is disrespectful to the organizers, it's disrespectful to the opponent" – Hans Niemann on Magnus Carlsen not showing up for his fast classic game against Bibisara Assaubayeva. pic.twitter.com/Bskm5ffOAR