Manchester United currently faces a period of volatility that leaves the club “almost unmanageable,” according to former professional player Dedryck Boyata.
In a recent analysis published by DHnet, the current state of the Premier League side is described as a difficult environment for any incoming manager to handle.
The assessment follows a turbulent start to the campaign that saw the departure of Ruud van Nistelrooy, who had stepped in as interim manager. “The situation was very complicated for Carrick,” Boyata told DHnet, referring to the period of transition. “I understand his dismissal: United hoped to start the season as they had finished it with Carrick. But finding themselves in November with a single league victory and in the relegation zone made the situation very complicated.”
The challenges at Old Trafford extend beyond the technical staff. Boyata pointed to public friction within the squad and the front office, specifically citing critiques regarding the team’s tactical identity and the management of football director Dan Ashworth. “Even more so with Fernandes’ criticisms of the play or Martinez’s [criticisms] on the management of football director Wilcox,” Boyata said.
Mauricio Pochettino has been identified as a figure capable of handling high-pressure roles, though the current circumstances at the club present a unique set of obstacles. “Pochettino has the experience of the pressure of big clubs,” Boyata said. “His management of players is interesting and every time he leaves, people speak well of him, notably in his construction of a collective. Even if here, Manchester United is almost unmanageable.”
Pochettino is expected to work under scrutiny from both the fanbase and the current leadership structure.
“He will have to work with leaders rejected by the supporters and he will want to be the one who gets MU out of the hole,” Boyata told DHnet. “He has the reputation of being a physically intense coach too, tactically sharp. But the circumstances for him are not easy.”
The squad depth remains a point of discussion, particularly regarding the role of Belgian international Youri Tielemans. Amid competition from players like Manuel Ugarte, Kobbie Mainoo, and Enzo Fernández, Boyata argues that Tielemans provides a necessary presence regardless of the tactical formation. “With Tielemans, Santos, Mainoo, Fernandez and Baleba, who is injured, there are five for two or three places depending on the scheme chosen in 3-4-3 or 4-2-3-1,” Boyata explained, according to DHnet.
“It is possible that Youri might not be a starter but honestly, whatever the animation, Youri must always play for me.”
Boyata highlighted that Tielemans has maintained a high level of performance during recent international windows. “He can be comfortable as a 10 or in a double pivot but then more with Mainoo than with Santos,” he said.
The current goalkeeping situation also appears settled, with Boyata noting that the start of the season has confirmed the status of the current number one. “Lammens’ start to the season has shown that he was the number one goalkeeper, especially since he is coming off a great international window,” Boyata told DHnet.
Worth a look