Manchester United defender Diogo Dalot has become a focal point of intense criticism following a series of defensive errors during the club’s 4-4 draw with Aston Villa on November 8, 2026.
The match, held at Old Trafford, saw the Portuguese international struggle to contain the opposition, specifically during an incident where he conceded a penalty after a foul on Alysson, which John McGinn subsequently converted.
Former striker Carlton Cole, speaking on the podcast The Dressing Room, described Dalot’s continued presence in the starting lineup as akin to “winning the lottery.” According to reporting by Bola.com, Cole suggested that the defender should have been sold several seasons ago, noting that the player frequently repeats the same tactical errors.
“He keeps making the same mistakes and always gets caught; he was at fault last week and he was at fault again over the weekend,” Cole said.
Despite the backlash from supporters, who were heard jeering when Dalot was substituted during the match, manager Michael Carrick has publicly defended his player. Speaking to the media after the game, Michael Carrick acknowledged the frustration felt by the Old Trafford crowd but emphasized that he would not blame a single player for the team’s defensive lapses, as reported by Bola.net.

“Diogo gives everything on the pitch. He has played in various positions, including as a left-back, and has performed very well on many occasions,” Carrick said. Goal.com noted that Carrick urged caution regarding calls to drop Dalot, stating that he understands the fans’ disappointment but remains focused on the collective culture of the squad.
Dalot, who joined Manchester United from Porto in 2018 for a reported fee of £19 million, has now made over 250 appearances for the club.
Despite his long tenure, his recent form has been highlighted by several analysts as a significant liability. iNews.id reported that the atmosphere at Old Trafford has become increasingly hostile, with supporters venting their anger directly toward the defender during the closing stages of the match against Aston Villa.
2 – Manchester United are the first team to trail by two goals and level twice in the same Premier League game. Whirlwind. pic.twitter.com/Qr7Hmjhp1M
The draw against Aston Villa extended Manchester United’s winless run in the Premier League to eight matches, leaving the club in 18th place. Goal.com confirmed that this marks the team’s lowest position at this stage of the season since the 1986-87 campaign.
The upcoming international break provides a brief respite for the squad to evaluate their tactical approach. The manager also said that Harry Maguire was substituted during the match due to a sudden back spasm, adding to the team’s current personnel concerns.

Manchester United is scheduled to return to action following the conclusion of the international break, as the club looks to improve its standing and secure a win to move out of the relegation zone.
Related reading