L’AS Saint-Étienne sits in a strong position atop the Ligue 2 table, yet data evaluations and fan sentiment point toward a clear roster priority when the winter transfer window opens. As reported by Peuple Vert and But! Football Club, questions surrounding the club’s left flank have prompted widespread discussion among supporters regarding whether the club should recruit a new left-back in January. Despite a super start to the 2026-2027 season, the club must still fine-tune a few points to have a complete and optimal squad.
Data Evaluations Highlight Left-Back Concerns
Despite collecting 25 points through their opening ten matches, Les Verts have experienced uneven individual performances across the squad under manager Ian Cathro, as detailed in Data’Scout evaluations cited by Peuple Vert. New Zealand international Ben Old recorded a rating of 37, marking the lowest evaluation among the club’s rated outfield players. By comparison, defensive options such as Kévin Pedro reached 61, João Ferreira hit 57, and Julien Le Cardinal posted a 53. While those positional differences prevent a direct tactical hierarchy, the figures underscore a noticeable statistical gap on the left side of the pitch where Old has seen regular minutes. At the top of this evaluation, Irvin Cardona reaches 69, ahead of Jakob Breum at 62 and Pedro at 61. The entry of Chico Lamba caused a reorganization of the defense. Later, the decisive goal against Nantes came from an action by Pedro, prolonged by Jaber’s cross for Boakye.
Supporters Overwhelmingly Favor Winter Recruitment
To gauge public sentiment on the matter, social media polls conducted by digital outlets such as But! Football Club and Peuple Vert asked fans whether the club should target a left-back when the market reopens, posing the question: L’ASSE doit-elle recruter un latéral gauche en janvier ?
The response proved decisive. Nearly seven out of ten respondents—specifically 68.4% of voters—voted in favor of adding a new left-side defender in January, while 31.6% preferred maintaining the current squad depth.
Balancing Financial Means and Sporting Ambitions
Comme le relève la source, la situation financière de Kilmer Group offre à Saint-Étienne des moyens pour envisager un recrutement si le staff en identifie le besoin. With the club pursuing an immediate return to Ligue 1, addressing squad balance remains a central priority for management. While no formal arrivals have been confirmed by the club’s administration, the upcoming winter transfer window offers an opportunity to solidify the left-back position as the promotion race intensifies. Clearly, in January 2027, management will need to correct this precise point and target a talented left-back with room to grow for the coming years.
Keep reading
