The Pittsburgh Steelers face an uncertain quarterback landscape as Aaron Rodgers enters free agency without a firm decision on his playing future, leaving front-office decision-makers weighing potential successors ranging from veteran options to incoming draft prospects.
According to reports, Aaron Rodgers remains an unsigned free agent who has not yet made a final commitment regarding whether he will return for another NFL season. Industry expectations point toward the veteran signal-caller suiting up for at least one more year, potentially under the guidance of newly appointed Pittsburgh head coach Mike McCarthy. McCarthy previously served as Rodgers’ head coach during their tenure with the Green Bay Packers, creating a ready-made tactical familiarity should the quarterback choose the Steel City.
Should Rodgers return, he would step into an overhauled Pittsburgh offense. Earlier in the offseason, the Steelers completed a trade with the Indianapolis Colts to acquire wide receiver Michael Pittman Jr., pairing him alongside wide receiver DK Metcalf to form a dynamic receiving tandem for any future Hall of Fame quarterback.
Yet the long-term reality remains stark for the franchise. Whether Rodgers decides to play through the upcoming campaign or steps away entirely, Pittsburgh must build a sustainable succession plan at the game’s most critical position. Analysts and league observers have pointed toward four distinct candidates the organization could evaluate to secure the position.
Evaluating Potential Successors: Anthony Richardson and the Draft Board
Among the external options frequently discussed in league circles is Indianapolis Colts quarterback Anthony Richardson. Having previously been selected fourth overall in the NFL Draft, Richardson has flashed elite physical traits but battled durability concerns and inconsistency during his early professional snaps. Given the existing trade relationship between Pittsburgh and Indianapolis earlier in the offseason, league observers note that a deal for Richardson could command a manageable acquisition cost relative to his high athletic ceiling.
Looking toward the collegiate ranks, Alabama Crimson Tide quarterback Ty Simpson has surfaced in several early mock drafts as a projected target for Pittsburgh with the 21st overall selection in the 2026 NFL Draft. If Simpson remains available when the Steelers go on the clock, talent evaluators view him as a logical positional fit. Penn State quarterback Drew Allar also represents an intriguing mid-round developmental prospect worth monitoring as draft boards take shape.
Internal Development: The Case for Will Howard
In addition to external acquisitions and draft projections, the Steelers retain internal alternatives within their quarterback room. Will Howard, formerly of Ohio State, enters the equation after Pittsburgh selected the signal-caller in the sixth round of the previous draft. Team leadership has expressed encouragement regarding his developmental arc, signaling that another year under professional coaching could position him to compete for snaps.
The urgency of the search hinges heavily on Rodgers’ immediate plans. Last season across 16 appearances, Rodgers completed 65.7 percent of his pass attempts, throwing for 3,322 yards, 24 touchdowns, and seven interceptions. Those numbers demonstrate that the veteran can still operate at a high competitive level, and a roster otherwise rich in talent would instantly thrust Pittsburgh into contention within the AFC if he elects to return.
As the franchise awaits official word from Rodgers, the front office continues mapping out contingency plans to ensure stability under center for both the immediate future and the years ahead.
Related reading
