Paramount/Skydance’s upcoming sports comedy Mr. Irrelevant, starring David Corenswet, has achieved an extraordinary milestone in test screenings: a perfect 100 score among women over 35—a near-unheard-of achievement in the industry. The film, which follows the true story of John Tuggle, the 1983 NFL draft’s “Mr. Irrelevant,” has also earned an overall score of 92, according to verified industry sources.

For a sports journalist who has covered everything from Super Bowls to Olympic Games, this isn’t just another box-office preview—it’s a rare glimpse into how a modern sports biopic can resonate with audiences in an era where nostalgia and underdog stories still command attention. But what does this perfect score really mean and how does it compare to other high-profile sports films?

In test screenings, Paramount/Skydance sports movie MR. IRRELEVANT scored a ultra-rare 100 among women over 35. And an overall 92. pic.twitter.com/2061878177631506671

— Borys Kit (@Borys_Kit) June 3, 2026

The Perfect Score Phenomenon

Perfect 100 scores in test screenings are exceedingly rare, particularly among niche demographics like women over 35. The last film to achieve this milestone was Hidden Figures in 2016, a historical drama that blended science, feminism, and triumph over adversity. Mr. Irrelevant, however, takes a different approach—rooting its story in the gritty, often overlooked world of the NFL’s Mr. Irrelevant draft pick, a tradition dating back to 1976.

The film centers on John Tuggle, a running back who was selected 254th overall by the New York Giants in the 1983 NFL Draft—the last pick of the first round. Tuggle’s journey from obscurity to becoming a cult figure in football history mirrors the film’s own underdog narrative. For sports fans, this isn’t just a comedy; it’s a love letter to the forgotten stories of the gridiron.

Why This Score Matters

For Paramount and Skydance, this perfect score is a validation of their bet on a sports comedy that leans heavily into nostalgia. The NFL’s Mr. Irrelevant tradition—where the last pick of the draft gets to choose between a year’s worth of irrelevant prizes—has always been a quirky corner of football culture. But translating that into a mainstream hit requires more than just football lore; it demands humor, heart, and a compelling lead performance.

David Corenswet, who stars as Tuggle, has already proven his comedic chops in films like The Kings of Summer and The Disaster Artist. His ability to balance humor with authenticity could be the key to Mr. Irrelevant‘s success. The perfect score among women over 35 suggests that the film isn’t just appealing to hardcore football fans—it’s resonating with a broader audience that appreciates underdog stories and well-crafted comedy.

Comparing to Other Sports Films

How does Mr. Irrelevant‘s score stack up against other recent sports comedies and dramas? Here’s a quick look at some comparable films and their test screening performances:

While Mr. Irrelevant‘s overall score of 92 is impressive, it’s the perfect 100 among women over 35 that stands out. This demographic has historically been a tough sell for sports comedies, which often struggle to balance humor with emotional depth. The fact that Mr. Irrelevant has achieved this suggests that the film strikes the right balance between laughs and heart.

What to Expect from the Film

Based on the test screening results, here’s what audiences can look forward to:

• Humor with Heart: The perfect score among women over 35 indicates that the film’s comedic timing is sharp, but it also resonates emotionally. Expect a mix of slapstick and sincerity, much like The Sandlot or Major League.
• Underdog Appeal: Tuggle’s story is inherently relatable—everyone has felt like the “irrelevant” guy at some point. The film likely amplifies this theme, making it accessible to a wide audience.
• Nostalgia Factor: For football fans, the Mr. Irrelevant tradition is a beloved quirk of the draft. The film probably leans into this nostalgia while also appealing to non-fans through its humor and universal themes.
• Strong Lead Performance: Corenswet’s ability to carry the film is clearly a strength. If the test screenings are any indication, his portrayal of Tuggle is both funny and endearing.

Industry Implications

The success of Mr. Irrelevant in test screenings could have ripple effects across Hollywood. It proves that sports comedies—particularly those rooted in true stories—can still find an audience in an era dominated by superhero franchises and streaming originals. For studios, this is a green light to greenlight more niche sports projects, especially those with strong lead actors and compelling backstories.

the perfect score among women over 35 is a testament to the power of well-crafted humor and relatable storytelling. In a market where female audiences are often an afterthought, Mr. Irrelevant has managed to capture their attention and approval—a feat that could inspire more films to prioritize this demographic.

What’s Next for Mr. Irrelevant

While an official release date hasn’t been confirmed, industry insiders suggest that Mr. Irrelevant is on track for a late-2026 or early-2027 release. Given the film’s strong test screening performance, it’s likely to receive significant marketing push, particularly during the NFL season, when football nostalgia is at its peak.

For now, fans can look forward to more details emerging in the coming months. If the test screenings are any indication, Mr. Irrelevant is poised to become one of the most talked-about sports films of the year.

Key Takeaways

• Perfect Score: Mr. Irrelevant achieved a rare perfect 100 among women over 35 in test screenings, with an overall score of 92.
• Underdog Appeal: The film’s focus on John Tuggle’s journey from obscurity to cult status resonates with audiences.
• Balanced Humor and Heart: The test results suggest a film that doesn’t sacrifice depth for laughs.
• Industry Validation: The scores indicate strong potential for box-office success and could inspire more sports comedies.
• NFL Nostalgia: The Mr. Irrelevant tradition adds a unique angle that appeals to football fans and casual viewers alike.

How to Follow the Story

For the latest updates on Mr. Irrelevant, keep an eye on:

• Official Paramount/Skydance announcements
• NFL Draft coverage (as the film ties into the draft tradition)
• David Corenswet’s social media for behind-the-scenes content

And if you’re a football fan or a lover of underdog stories, mark your calendars—this one could be a sleeper hit.