California voters rejected the “Proposition 40” tax measure on November 3, turning down a proposal that sought to levy an exceptional tax on the state’s approximately 240 billionaires.
The defeat of the initiative highlights a recurring tension in fiscal policy: while voters often support taxing the ultra-wealthy in principle, they frequently resist specific mechanisms that target accumulated capital. Behavioral economists point to “loss aversion” as a primary driver behind this phenomenon, noting that individuals perceive the pain of losing existing assets more acutely than the pleasure of gaining a comparable amount.
In experiments conducted by Nobel laureate Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky, participants consistently demanded a potential gain of roughly double the amount they risked losing in a coin-flip scenario. This psychological asymmetry suggests that taxing realized income is often viewed as more acceptable than reclassifying or removing portions of a person’s established net worth.
“Taxing a gain seems more acceptable than amputating the same amount from existing assets,” says Olivier Sibony, a professor at HEC Paris, noting that this logic mirrors the patterns seen in Californian electoral behavior.
The resistance to taxing wealth rather than income echoes historical debates surrounding France’s former solidarity tax on wealth, known as the ISF. While the ISF sparked significant public discourse and claims of capital flight, income taxes—even those that generated higher total payments for many of the same individuals—historically faced less intense opposition.
The focus in public debate often shifted toward narrow exceptions, such as individuals with high-value assets but modest cash flow, rather than the broader impact of the levy itself.
Research published in 2022 further illustrates this preference for the status quo. When asked whether to tax stock gains annually as they accrue or only at the moment of sale, a broad majority of Americans—including those without personal investments—supported taxing only realized gains. This preference aligns with the endowment effect, where individuals place higher subjective value on assets they already possess compared to potential acquisitions.
Although California maintains some of the highest marginal income and capital gains tax rates in the United States, the proposal to specifically target the capital of the ultra-wealthy encountered a different threshold of public consent. The rejection of Proposition 40 suggests that even in a state with high tax tolerance, the political cost of targeting existing wealth remains a formidable barrier.
For those advocating for wealth-based levies, the challenge remains psychological as much as it is political. Evidence suggests that the public is more likely to accept fiscal measures that do not trigger the perceived “loss” of already acquired assets, making income-based taxation a more stable, if less targeted, instrument for state revenue.
Worth a look