The administrative litigation division of the Tribunal Superior de Justícia de Catalunya must rule on remote work for senior officials in the Generalitat after lower courts issued contradictory rulings on the matter, Ara.cat reported.
A Barcelona administrative litigation court annulled the remote work veto for deputy directors in the Generalitat’s business department. That decision directly opposed another ruling that upheld the restriction for officials in the economy department. The high court in Catalonia will now have to establish a single criterion.
Represented by lawyer Benet Salellas, the plaintiffs successfully argued that the instruction prohibiting remote work violated a higher-ranking provision, according to Ara.cat.
The judge said that the instruction ordering in-person attendance for deputy directors contradicted a 2020 decree. That decree established that remote work applied to personnel serving the Catalan administration and its autonomous bodies.
The court found that the government instruction clearly modified remote work regulations and innovated within the legal system by eliminating the modality entirely for deputy directors and equivalent positions. The ruling concluded that the instruction was void by law because it breached a higher administrative provision.
Because of the normative character of the instruction, the judge lacked the competence to declare the provision itself null. Consequently, the court opened the door to raising an issue of illegality for the Tribunal Superior de Justícia de Catalunya to resolve.
This division contrasts directly with a separate ruling issued by Barcelona administrative litigation court number 14. That court upheld the remote work veto for deputy directors, finding that the government could demand in-person work given the responsibilities assigned to those roles.
The court ruled that the government could require continuous physical presence for those officials, who form the final administrative tier before political appointees.
“The remote work modality is not configured as a subjective right of the personnel, but rather as an alternative in work organization as a discretionary power of the administration,” the economy department ruling said.
The presidency department, led by Albert Dalmau, argued previously that distance work was difficult to reconcile with the nature and inherent responsibilities of a deputy director general. The department cited a high degree of strategic responsibility and team coordination duties as reasons for the requirement.
The restriction took effect through an instruction issued on January 7, 2025. It applied to deputy directors general and equivalent roles across the administration.
Around a hundred senior executives within the Generalitat had requested authorization at the time to work remotely for a maximum of two days per week.
The Tribunal Superior de Justícia de Catalunya will examine the conflicting lower court interpretations to determine the legal limits of remote work for high-ranking regional officials.
Worth a look