Supreme Court Rejects LaLiga Appeal, Confirms Nulity of Initial CVC Agreement

The Tribunal Supremo dismissed a cassation appeal filed by LaLiga against a Madrid Provincial Court ruling that confirmed the nullity of the league’s August 12, 2021, general assembly agreement regarding an investment pact with CVC Capital Partners, according to Diario AS.

The ruling stems from legal challenges brought forward by Real Madrid and Athletic Club regarding the initial vote, according to Diario AS.

According to ESdiario, the high court’s refusal to admit the appeal leaves no further avenues for the league to contest the annulment of that specific August meeting. The initial assembly had faced scrutiny over documentation timing and procedural guarantees before club representatives cast their votes.

“El Tribunal Supremo confirma así la firmeza de la declaración judicial de nulidad de un acuerdo de extraordinaria trascendencia económica, adoptado sin que los clubes dispusieran de información suficiente para conocer y valorar el alcance, el impacto y las consecuencias de las modificaciones introducidas en la operación,” said Real Madrid in an official club statement.

Supreme Court Rejects LaLiga Appeal, Confirms Nulity of Initial CVC Agreement
Photo: ESdiario

Legal Scrutiny Over August 2021 Assembly

The core of the dispute centered on the information made available to clubs prior to the August 2021 vote. The Provincial Court previously determined that alterations introduced during the process compromised the voting members’ right to sufficient detail. In March 2025, the Provincial Court of Madrid ratified the ruling from the Court of First Instance number 47 of Madrid, which declared the assembly void due to substantial changes in the previously approved agenda.

Among the reasons for the nullity were the convocation with only eight days’ notice—compared to the ten required for an ordinary meeting—the delivery of documentation just two days prior, and changes made during the voting process itself.

“El Real Madrid considera que esta resolución constituye un nuevo y contundente respaldo judicial a su defensa de los derechos de los clubes frente a actuaciones de LaLiga, que vulneran las garantías que deben regir el funcionamiento de sus órganos de gobierno,” the club added in its published release.

The club also said that the Supreme Court said LaLiga, in its appeal, intended to substitute the Provincial Court's criteria with its own interested viewpoint.

While the first agreement was struck down, subsequent votes followed a different trajectory. As noted by Crónica Global, a second general assembly convened on December 10, 2021, where participating clubs voted by majority to commit a 10.95% share of audiovisual rights over a 50-year term in exchange for a projected global investment of approximately 1,994 million euros.

In June 2026, the Provincial Court of Madrid upheld those agreements and dismissed the appeal filed by Real Madrid and Athletic Club.

LaLiga Dismisses Ruling Impact

LaLiga issued a counter-statement maintaining that the Supreme Court’s latest procedural dismissal carries no practical impact on the overarching commercial agreement. The league emphasized that the ruling addresses strictly formal aspects of the initial summer meeting.

According to Mundo Deportivo, the organization stressed that the resolution does not invalidate Proyecto LALIGA Impulso. The league asserted that the substantive matters of the partnership were validated in separate legal proceedings where courts dismissed opposing claims from Athletic Club and Real Madrid.

Supreme Court Rejects LaLiga Appeal, Confirms Nulity of Initial CVC Agreement
Photo: IUSPORT

“La resolución no afecta a la validez ni a la vigencia del Proyecto LALIGA Impulso con CVC, aprobado posteriormente por la Asamblea General del 10 de diciembre de 2021,” LaLiga stated through its official channels, as cited by Europa Press.

“Las cuestiones de fondo de este proyecto se han abordado en un procedimiento judicial independiente, en el que la Audiencia Provincial de Madrid desestimó las pretensiones de los dos clubes demandantes, Real Madrid CF y Athletic Club, y confirmó la validez de los acuerdos adoptados,” explained the organization led by Javier Tebas, according to MARCA.

football Desk

football Desk at Archysport.