Rutgers shocked Penn State 25-24 on a walk-off lateral and two-point conversion at Beaver Stadium on Saturday, handing the Nittany Lions their first loss to the Scarlet Knights since 1988.
Rutgers (3-8, 2-6 Big Ten) erased a 16-0 second-quarter deficit and a 24-10 fourth-quarter hole to stun Penn State (6-5, 3-5) on Senior Day.
The winning sequence unfolded with no time remaining: quarterback AJ Surace hit Antwan Raymond in the flat, Raymond was wrapped up short of the goal line and lateraled to Ben Black III, who walked into the end zone. Instead of overtime, coach Greg Schiano went for the win, and Surace found Clay Thevenin for the conversion.
RUTGERS WALKS IT OFF WITH A TWO-POINT CONVERSION! What an end to the game for @RFootball pic.twitter.com/SICRoVJ6Lp
The game was played at West Shore Home Field at Beaver Stadium and presented by the Penn State Alumni Association as Senior Day. Starting running back Carson Hansen was declared out hours before kickoff.
Penn State’s offense managed just 20 plays and 39 yards in the second half, gaining only one first down over its final two possessions. The Nittany Lions ran 12 carries for 39 yards in the second half while Rutgers held a 19:38 to 10:22 advantage in time of possession and outgained Penn State 134-114 after halftime.
Penn State coach Matt Campbell after the Nittany Lions gave up 16- and 14-point leads in a 25-24 loss to Rutgers. pic.twitter.com/0ZRNrwZ588
Surace plays through injury to engineer rally
Surace, playing with three fractured ribs, had thrown zero passes in practice all week. “I’ll let you guys in on a little secret. AJ threw zero passes in practice this week. We made a calculated decision that the best way for him to heal was not to torque his body, so he did everything mentally, and he worked like crazy in treatment. But I’m really, really proud of that kid,” Schiano said.
Surace completed nine of 16 passes in the fourth quarter and directed a 19-play, 75-yard drive that consumed 9:38 and cut the lead to 24-17.
Unbelievable. #Rutgers had scored 10 points over the last two weeks combined, got eight in the final six seconds to beat #PennState. pic.twitter.com/TJ9yDncQ9V
Raymond finished with 101 yards and two touchdowns on 23 carries. His 13-yard score with 10:19 left made it a one-possession game. Penn State’s offense managed just 20 plays and 39 yards in the second half.
Injuries mount for Penn State offense
Multiple Nittany Lions left the game due to injury. Running back James Peoples, wide receiver Brett Eskildsen, tight end Andrew Rappleyea, and center Brock Riker all got hurt at various points, with Eskildsen and Peoples going out early and missing the rest of the action.
Thirty-eight years of misery ended for Rutgers with one of the most improbable victories in program history. Enjoy it, Rutgers fans, and don't worry about what comes next. Column: https://t.co/yCInrbdZ1U
Peoples was carried off the field after a first-quarter tackle by Rutgers’ Latrell Noel. Penn State had already been without one of its best weapons in wide receiver Koby Howard.
Campbell takes responsibility for preparation
Penn State led 16-0 after Cam Wallace’s 56-yard opening touchdown and a Chase Sowell 17-yard catch, but the Nittany Lions failed to convert fourth-and-goal from the 1-yard line twice in the first half and settled for a safety.
SAFETY!!! Josiah Zayas makes the play 😤 Penn State 9, Rutgers 0 pic.twitter.com/zeA3qeoxrn
“I didn't have the team prepared to play its best football game, senior day, the end of the season, and that really hurts me,” Campbell said. “The reality of it is, it's a mentality to play 60 minutes to a standard, and that is not where we're at yet.”
Redshirt junior Cam Wallace opened the scoring with a 56-yard rush at the 10:22 mark of the first quarter, capping a three-play, 71-yard sequence. He finished with 95 yards on 16 carries. The Nittany Lions led 9-0 after 15 minutes and widened the margin to 16-0 on Sowell’s 17-yard touchdown catch, a six-play, 61-yard drive that featured a 27-yard reception by Brahmer.

Penn State could not convert on fourth down on its next offensive sequence, and the Scarlet Knights settled for a field goal after a fumble by quarterback Rocco Becht was recovered by Rutgers as the clock dwindled in the first half. Penn State led 16-10 at halftime.
Penn State committed two pass-interference penalties on the final drive, the second on fourth-and-8. “At the end of the day, you can't leave it to chance. And unfortunately, we left it to chance,” Campbell said. “It has nothing to do with officiating and everything to do with our inconsistencies.”
Cam Wallace opened up the game with a 56-yard rushing TD 💥@PennStateFBall leads 16-10 over Rutgers 🦁 pic.twitter.com/FOqDVVnDPN
Offensive lineman Anthony Donkoh, listed at 6-5, 324 pounds, took part in Senior Day celebrations pregame and has one year of eligibility remaining. It sucks, Donkoh said. “I don't really have anything else to say. We have to move forward. We have to learn from today. It's easy to say we've got to win the moments, but nobody knows when the moment is coming.”
Schiano’s full-circle moment
Schiano, a Penn State defensive backs coach from 1991 to 1995, returned to Beaver Stadium two weeks after athletic director Keli Zinn announced he would return for a 19th season in 2027.
Rutgers is expected to start AJ Surace at quarterback today against Penn State, sources tell @CBSSports. Has been working through injury and played as an emergency option last week. Now set to start against Penn State. pic.twitter.com/KpIvE8kA6V
“There's a lot of history in this building, personally. … It was a lot of thought driving in here last night. I have a lot of special memories here, but I don't know if any of them are more special than this,” Schiano said. “1988, that's the last time we did it here.”
“I'm really, really proud of this team, their faith, their belief in what we do. It would have been easy to say, 'this isn't our year,' and 'let's get to next year.' But there hasn't been any of that the whole season,” Schiano said.
“But this is a good lesson for our guys, what life is about. It doesn't always come when you want it. But you've got to keep chopping; you've got to keep fighting.”
Rutgers had scored a combined 10 points in its previous two games, blowout defeats to Wisconsin and Nebraska, and had been shut out by Nebraska the week prior. The Scarlet Knights hadn’t scored a touchdown in State College since 1994, a span of five games. Entering as 26.5-point underdogs, Rutgers logged its first win since Oct. 17 and just its second victory over an FBS opponent during the 2026 campaign.
Quarterback Rocco Becht, who spent four seasons under Campbell at Iowa State before following him to Penn State, said, “I've been here for a year, but the guys that have stayed here and were here for four or five years, I was playing for them today. I know guys were playing for me, but shoot, they don't got to play for me.”
The game marked the first meeting between the programs at the venue since it was officially renamed West Shore Home Field at Beaver Stadium in 2025 following a naming rights agreement. The stadium, which opened in 1960 after the previous facility was moved and reconstructed on the current site, has been expanded six times and now seats 106,572, making it the second-largest in the Western Hemisphere.
Penn State closes the regular season next Saturday at Maryland (3:30 p.m., FS1). Rutgers, bowl-eligible for the first time since 2023, awaits its postseason destination.