NHL Quarter-Mark Report Cards: Grading Every Team at 2026-27 Season Milestone

The 2026-27 NHL season has reached its quarter-point, a traditional milestone where teams are evaluated based on their performance through the first 20 to 22 games. While some clubs have solidified their standing, others face significant roster challenges and performance gaps as the league approaches the end of November.

Rangers Maintain Competitive Standing

They currently sit five points clear of the Islanders and seven points ahead of the Washington Capitals, though their rivals hold multiple games in hand. This performance is particularly notable given the loss of Igor Shesterkin to season-ending knee surgery; the team’s ability to maintain a points percentage over .600 has earned them a high mark in league assessments.

Through 22 games, the Rangers have established themselves as a defense-first team, tied for the fifth-best goals-against average in the league at 2.64. While the team averages 3.05 goals per game—ranking 19th in the NHL—they possess the ability to generate offense off the rush or through skill plays from contributors such as Mika Zibanejad, Alexis Lafreniere, Pavel Dorofeyev, and Gabe Perreault.

The team has seen a significant turnaround at home, boasting a 9-2-0 record at Madison Square Garden, a stark improvement from the previous season. Having recently completed a swing through the Northwest, the club is currently enjoying a five-day break in their schedule.

Lucas raymond red wings
Photo: thehockeywriters.com

Maple Leafs Address Performance Gaps

The Toronto Maple Leafs find themselves in a difficult position, having dropped six of their last seven games, all in regulation. With a 8-10-2 record through 20 games, the team has fallen to seventh in the Atlantic Division.

The current atmosphere surrounding the club is described as a “sluggish morning,” as the team struggles to control play and lock down chaos in their own end. No Eastern Conference team has surrendered more 5-on-5 goals than Toronto’s 50.

The roster is currently battling health issues, with 36-year-old Chris Tanev undergoing load management and Morgan Rielly sidelined by a non-contact injury. Veterans Oliver Ekman-Larsson and Jake McCabe have not performed with the consistency displayed last season.

In the crease, the team’s .883 save percentage ranks 21st league-wide, with the goaltending tandem needing to elevate their play to a higher standard for the team to remain a postseason contender. Despite these setbacks, the team is relying on youth, with 18-year-old McKenna leading the rookie scoring race and Easton Cowan contributing in the top six.

Red Wings and League Context

For the Detroit Red Wings, the first quarter of the season has been described as “nightmarish.” The team is missing two of its five most talented players in Dylan Larkin and Simon Edvinsson, which has taken a clear toll on their standing.

While the team struggles to finish in a tough division, Lucas Raymond remains a bright spot; he leads the team with eight goals and 21 points, putting him on pace for an 80-point season, and his three game-winning goals rank seventh among all NHL players.

Jim Hiller talks to the media following his Maple Leafs' 6-3 loss to the Colorado Avalanche
Photo: sportsnet.ca

Elsewhere, the Calgary Flames, while not currently a playoff team, are seeing competitive play from a young core including Zayne Parekh, Matthew Coronato, and Matvei Gridin. The Dallas Stars have seen their “big guns”—Jason Robertson, Mikko Rantanen, Wyatt Johnston, and Roope Hintz—all reach approximately a point-per-game pace, supported by the return of Miro Heiskanen and Jake Oettinger to form.

Meanwhile, the Winnipeg Jets have managed to remain in the thick of the playoff race despite a challenging start, following a nine-game losing streak with a subsequent six-game winning streak.

Depth and Coaching Outlook

Players such as Nick Paul, Colton Sissons, Dakota Joshua, Brandon Duhaime, Teddy Blueger, and Zack MacEwen are currently not on pace to exceed eight goals this season. For teams like the Maple Leafs, this lack of second-wave offense places immense pressure on their core.

As the league approaches U.S. Thanksgiving marks the quarter-point of the season, and general managers are using it to assess whether their current rosters can sustain a playoff push or if major structural changes are needed to reach their postseason goals.

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archysport.