Jean-Luc Mélenchon and La France Insoumise face a latent conflict with the Conseil Constitutionnel that could explode in the event of a victory by Jean-Luc Mélenchon in the presidential election, according to reports published by L’Express.fr.
The public confrontation between Constitutional Council president Richard Ferrand and the Rassemblement national conceals another latent conflict between the Sages and La France Insoumise that could explode if Jean-Luc Mélenchon wins the presidency.
The core dispute centers on Article 11 of the 1958 French Constitution.
Party figures contend that the Senate would obstruct their reform agenda. “Des constitutionnalistes nous disent qu’il y a un chemin, assure la députée LFI Clémence Guetté à Libération. Si nous passions par l’article 89, le Sénat ferait obstruction car c’est une chambre conservatrice,” said Clémence Guetté, LFI deputy, in an interview with Libération.
Denys de Béchillon, professor emeritus at the University of Pau and the Pays de l’Adour, said that any substantial modification to the text constitutes a constitutional revision regardless of the chosen article.
Jean-Luc Mélenchon’s distrust of the constitutional judges is long-standing. On November 6, 2017, following the council’s rejection of a 3 percent tax on dividends, he criticized the institution directly. “Depuis quand doit-on tomber à genoux parce que le Conseil a parlé ? Le Conseil n’est qu’une assemblée humaine,” said Jean-Luc Mélenchon.
Further friction occurred in 2023 when Mélenchon accused the council of issuing a heavy blow to the populace after it validated the government’s contested pension reform. Party members have frequently argued that legal compliance does not equal democratic legitimacy.
According to Emmanuel Maurel, deputy for Val-d’Oise and head of the Gauche républicaine et socialiste, the legicentrist tradition stemming from the Revolution is characterized by a distrust of constitutional review because it would go against the expression of national sovereignty by the Assembly.
If La France Insoumise wins power in 2027, several radical fiscal proposals—including a wealth tax associated with Gabriel Zucman, a strict cap on inheritances, and steeper income tax progression—would face immediate scrutiny from the constitutional judges. Pierre Crétois, co-author of the party’s constitutional booklet and political philosophy lecturer, emphasized that the current institutional framework protects economic liberties at the expense of social welfare measures.
As political preparations continue ahead of the 2027 election cycle, the debate over whether popular sovereignty supersedes established constitutional review remains a central point of division across the French political spectrum.
Keep reading
- SPORT Sports Values Awards: Rafa Nadal, Rodri, and Hansi Flick Honored at La Pedrera Gala
- Vladimir Putin Congratulates Mirra Andreeva on WTA Finals Victory
- IC City Council to Consider Historic St. Mary’s Catholic Church Appeal – The Daily Iowan (bytewire.news)
- Flagship London council’s huge cuts plan as households face 100% council tax rise (newsarchyuk.com)