Federica Pellegrini Sends Legal Notice to Matteo Bassetti Over Fever Comments

Federica Pellegrini has initiated legal action against infectious disease specialist Matteo Bassetti following public criticism of her comments regarding competing while ill, according to Corriere della sera.

The dispute, which began on social media, centers on an October 15 video in which the former Olympic swimmer described her past experiences to young athletes at her Fede Academy.

In the video, Pellegrini recounted a past competition where she participated despite having a fever of 40°C and a shoulder injury. She used the story to encourage her students to persevere through physical challenges, famously stating, “Ho gareggiato anche con 40 di febbre e una spalla che non girava” (I even competed with a 40-degree fever and a shoulder that wouldn’t rotate). She further noted, “Se la sera prima vi viene un cagotto, il giorno dopo non gareggiate? Esatto, gareggiamo anche con la febbre. Poi dipende da quanto uno lo vuole” (If you get diarrhea the night before, do you not compete the next day? Exactly, we even compete with a fever.

Then it depends on how much one wants it). Bassetti, the director of the infectious diseases clinic at Policlinico San Martino in Genoa, responded on Instagram by questioning the example set for young athletes, stating, "One does not compete with a 40-degree fever, according to La Gazzetta dello Sport. It is not an act of heroism," as reported by Corriere della Sera.

He added, “C’è una differenza fondamentale tra raccontare la propria esperienza e trasmettere un messaggio che altri, soprattutto i più giovani, potrebbero interpretare come un esempio da seguire” (There is a fundamental difference between telling one’s own experience and transmitting a message that others, especially the younger ones, could interpret as an example to follow).

Law firm demands post removal within 48 hours

The situation escalated on November 10 when the law firm Munari & Partners, representing Pellegrini and her academy, sent a formal notice to Bassetti. The document demanded the removal of the contested posts within 48 hours, alleging that the doctor had "maliciously and instrumentally misrepresented" her autobiographical account, according to reports from Il Fatto Quotidiano. The legal complaint has since been filed with the Public Prosecutor’s Office in Genoa.

Bassetti’s legal team, consisting of Massimo Boggio, Paolo Canepa, and Cesare Bruzzone, rejected the request. In a statement shared by the professor on X, his counsel noted, "The professor has expressed an evaluation on the content of a public message, within the limits of correctness and expressive restraint. He did not level insults nor attribute untruthful facts," La Gazzetta dello Sport reported.

Diverging perspectives on the dispute

The conflict highlights a disagreement over the limits of public critique and professional responsibility. The following points summarize the positions held by both parties:

Federica Pellegrini Sends Legal Notice to Matteo Bassetti Over Fever Comments
Photo: La Gazzetta dello Sport
  • Federica Pellegrini’s position: Her legal representatives argue that the video was a sharing of personal experience intended to motivate, and that Bassetti’s subsequent attempts to link her statements to those of her husband, Matteo Giunta—who had previously criticized parents for sending sick children to school—were instrumental and misleading, according to Il Tempo.
  • Matteo Bassetti’s position: The doctor maintains that he was exercising his right to provide scientific commentary on matters of public interest. His defense team said that he did not intend to damage the swimmer’s career or reputation, and they refused the request to remove the content, as noted by GenovaToday.

Bassetti, who has also discussed the topic on San Marino Rtv, has expressed his surprise at the legal action, stating he remains firm in his right to offer medical opinions on issues that could influence public health behaviors, Virgilio reported.

Respinging accusations of malice, his team noted, “Nessuna delle sue dichiarazioni ha inteso lederne la persona o la carriera” (None of his statements intended to harm her person or career). As of November 18, the legal representatives for the professor have indicated that they do not intend to comply with the removal requests.

Broader public engagements

Beyond the legal battle, Pellegrini has continued her public appearances. The Region of Liguria recently celebrated her during the Orientamenti Festival at the Magazzini del Cotone in Genoa, where she was awarded the title of “Ligurian Sportsperson of 2026.”

Additionally, she served as the guest of honor at the University of Ca’ Foscari in Venice for their graduation day, addressing one thousand new graduates: “Provo una profonda emozione e nel guardarvi rivedo me stessa chiedermi, dopo aver dedicato una larga parte della mia vita a uno stesso obiettivo: e adesso?” (I feel a deep emotion and in looking at you I see myself asking, after having dedicated a large part of my life to one same goal: and now?).

On the professional front, the former swimmer also appeared as a guest on Rai Kids and Rai Yoyo for new episodes of the series Lampadino e Caramella.

Born in 1988, Federica Pellegrini is a retired swimmer from Mirano who achieved significant historical milestones in the sport. She became the first female Olympic swimming champion from Italy and remains the only swimmer, male or female, to have won eight consecutive medals in the same event at the World Championships.

Her career was defined by numerous world records, including becoming the first woman to break the 4-minute barrier in the 400-meter freestyle at the 2009 World Championships in Rome.

Furthermore, at the 2020 Summer Olympics, Federica Pellegrini became the first female swimmer to qualify for five consecutive Olympic finals in the 200-meter freestyle. A member of the International Olympic Committee, she retired from active competition in 2021 after a career that also saw her become the only Italian swimmer to set world records in more than one event.

The dispute is still an active legal case, a sharp escalation from what began as a social media exchange about the health standards of professional athletes.

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archysport.