Fan Poll: Kane Third, Henry Second in BBC’s 21st Century European Strikers Ranking

Harry Kane placed third and Thierry Henry finished second in a poll of tens of thousands of football fans selecting the top European strikers of the 21st century.

BBC Sport organized the vote using a 20-player shortlist compiled by an expert panel. European football analysts Guillem Balagué, Julien Laurens, and Rafael Honigstein subsequently discussed the results on the Euro Leagues podcast.

Honigstein stated in the podcast discussion, “I don’t think anyone is better at finishing right now in world football.”

Laurens said that Kane experienced a less conventional youth career compared to his peers on the list. Kane departed the Premier League three years ago as Tottenham Hotspur’s record goalscorer and the competition’s second-highest scorer in history.

Henry Claims Second Place as Sole Retired Player in Top Six

Henry secured the second position, standing as the only retired player among the top six selections. The French forward won the World Cup and European Championship with France, scored 228 goals while winning titles at Arsenal, and captured a Champions League trophy with Barcelona.

Honigstein assessed Henry’s impact by stating, “In his era, I don’t think there was anyone like him in the Premier League.”

Robert Lewandowski landed in fourth place. At 38 years old, the Polish forward currently plays for Chicago Fire in Major League Soccer following stints with Barcelona, Bayern Munich, and Borussia Dortmund.

Honigstein pointed out that Lewandowski practiced basketball, judo, and handball during his youth, developing a complete skill set for a central striker. Laurens added that Lewandowski earned a Ballon d’Or during a pandemic-affected voting period, noting, “We all know that was his.”

Haaland and Mbappé Round Out the Top Six

Erling Haaland took fifth place. The 26-year-old Manchester City striker has surpassed 300 career club goals and netted 68 goals in 61 appearances for Norway, according to Dongqiudi.

Balagué highlighted that Haaland scored 52 goals in 53 matches during the 2002–23 season while noting an ongoing stretch of 11 finals without scoring. Honigstein described Haaland’s physical attributes, stating, “He can sprint like a 100-meter runner.”

Kylian Mbappé finished sixth.

Laurens predicted that Mbappé’s ranking would rise in future votes, noting that the player has surpassed 400 career goals. Balagué emphasized Mbappé’s record of 22 goals in 22 matches across the World Cup and European Championship, while Honigstein asserted that no player matched his footballing ability heading toward 2026.

Strikers Completing the Top Ten Selection

Wayne Rooney, the all-time leading scorer for Manchester United and the first English player on the list, placed seventh. Honigstein argued that injuries and an unprofessional lifestyle prevented Rooney from reaching his absolute ceiling, remarking that “he could have been Messi.” Laurens characterized him as the most street-football-styled player in English football history.

Zlatan Ibrahimović took eighth place with a career total exceeding 500 goals across clubs including Malmö, Ajax, Juventus, both Milan clubs, Barcelona, Paris Saint-Germain, Manchester United, and LA Galaxy. Balagué referenced Ibrahimović scoring four goals against England, highlighted by his bicycle kick.

Ruud van Nistelrooy ranked ninth after scoring 150 goals for Manchester United. Honigstein called him a phenomenal penalty-box hunter, while Laurens praised his unique spatial awareness inside the area despite sustaining numerous injuries.

Laurens noted that Kane experienced a less conventional youth career, having been released by Arsenal’s academy at age eight before joining Tottenham Hotspur at eleven following a trial at Watford.

He made his senior debut for Spurs in 2009 and spent loan spells at Leyton Orient, Millwall, Leicester City, and Norwich City before establishing himself under Mauricio Pochettino in 2014. Kane departed the Premier League in 2023 as Tottenham’s record goalscorer with 280 goals and the competition’s second-highest scorer in history with 213, joining Bayern Munich for a Bundesliga-record €110 million fee.

Karim Benzema rounded out the top ten. Laurens credited Benzema with carrying Real Madrid following the departure of Cristiano Ronaldo, and Honigstein emphasized his selflessness and team-oriented play.

judo Desk

judo Desk at Archysport.