Eight Players Sent Off as América vs. New York Red Bulls Friendly Ends in Mass Brawl

A preseason friendly between Club América and the New York Red Bulls dissolved into a mass confrontation in the 84th minute Saturday night, leaving eight players ejected and overshadowing a 1-0 Red Bulls victory at Sports Illustrated Stadium in Harrison, New Jersey, according to UnoTV.

What began as a low-intensity exhibition in 6-degree Celsius (43 Fahrenheit) conditions ended with benches clearing, punches thrown, and four players from each side sent off, UnoTV reported. The Red Bulls took the lead in the 58th minute through Argentine forward Nehuén Benedetti, but the result became a footnote once the brawl erupted.

“La mayoría eran de la 21, se conocen bien, son amigos y obvio que saltaron a defenderse entre ellos,” comentaron fuentes sobre la situación. The Mexico City giants fielded a heavily youth-oriented lineup during the FIFA international window, with regular starters rested ahead of the Liga MX playoffs.

Donkor kicks Borja triggering mass brawl

The flashpoint arrived when América striker Miguel Borja challenged Red Bulls midfielder Ronald Donkor for a loose ball near the touchline, according to ESPN Costa Rica. Ronald Donkor pateó a Miguel Borja cuando el balón ya no estaba en disputa, según trascendió. América players — mostly academy graduates — rushed to confront Donkor, triggering a melee that migrated toward a corner flag and lasted several minutes.

Footage shows Andy Rojas, a New York Red Bulls player wearing the number 70 jersey, shoving a young América player and then throwing punches that struck Dagoberto Espinoza in the face, leaving him lying on the pitch. Goalkeeper Rodolfo Cota and teammates intervened to shield Espinoza while the altercation continued around them.

Referee intervention restored order long enough to issue red cards. América lost Espinoza, Emilio Lara, Ramón Juárez, and a player identified as Valle. The Red Bulls saw Benedetti, Bazán, Marshall-Rutty, and Mosquera dismissed. Both sides finished with seven men.

Divergent accounts on discipline

Sources differ on the exact number of ejections. UnoTV and La Opinión list four per team. TUDN and El Universal initially reported three per side, though El Universal noted additional América players — Alan Cervantes and Miguel Vázquez — threw punches without being sent off. The discrepancy reflects the chaos of a scene where officials struggled to identify every aggressor.

Because the match was a friendly, the red cards carry no competitive suspension.

Borja’s role questioned inside the locker room

Borja did not engage physically after the initial foul on him, a decision that frustrated some teammates.

Eight Players Sent Off as América vs. New York Red Bulls Friendly Ends in Mass Brawl
Photo: ESPN Costa Rica

The Colombian forward later had América’s best chance to equalize, breaking clear in stoppage time only to sky his shot over the crossbar.

América winless streak reaches five matches

América managed few clear chances before the brawl. Rodolfo Cota made at least three first-half saves to keep the game scoreless, while Emilio Lara was the visitors’ most active attacker down the right flank. The Red Bulls controlled territory and transitions throughout a match played at walking pace for long stretches.

The loss extends América’s winless run to five matches across all competitions heading into the Liga MX liguilla. Their next fixture is a home quarterfinal first leg against Tigres UANL on November 21 at Estadio Azteca — a tie that will test whether the defensive frailties and finishing issues on display in New Jersey have been addressed.

For the Red Bulls, the win offers a morale boost before their MLS Cup playoff push. Since it was a friendly, no sanctions apply, so the América players who were sent off will be eligible for the club’s next official and friendly match without any issue.

What remains unclear

Neither club has released an official medical update on Espinoza, who remained on the pitch for several minutes after the punches. The referee’s match report — which will determine if any supplementary discipline is warranted — has not been made public. América’s coaching staff has not commented on whether the brawl will alter selection plans for the Tigres series.

Club América, founded on 12 October 1916 by students from Colegio Mascarones and Colegio Marista de la Perpetua, chose its name because the merger occurred on Columbus Day. The club became the first Mexican side to play abroad in 1926 and supplied most of the national team for the 1928 Olympics and the 1930 World Cup.

Owned by Televisa since 1959, América holds a record sixteen Liga MX titles and seven CONCACAF Champions Cup crowns, the most in the region. In 2024 it became the first Mexican club to list on the Bolsa Mexicana de Valores.

The decision was to turn the page immediately, as once they left the stadium where the match took place, nothing more was said about it.

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archysport.