FRANKFURT —
German Football Association president Bernd Neuendorf is confronting a widening revolt from regional associations over his preferred plan to restructure the fourth tier, one month before delegates vote at an extraordinary DFB Bundestag on Dec. 18.
The Nordostdeutscher Fußball-Verband (NOFV), the eastern regional body where the reform push originated, announced this week that five of its six state associations oppose Neuendorf’s favored “Kompassmodell,” Welt reported. The defection leaves the president’s proposal — which would reduce five Regionalligas to four and redistribute clubs annually using an algorithm — short of the two-thirds majority required to amend DFB statutes.
Simultaneously, the Bavarian Football Association has formally submitted a competing “22/5” proposal that would expand the 3. Liga from 20 to 22 clubs and relegate five teams each season, preserving the existing five Regionalligas and guaranteeing promotion for all five league champions.
How the Kompassmodell lost its mandate
Neuendorf made the Regionalliga overhaul a personal priority after years of frustration over the current system, which promotes only four of five regional champions each season via a rotation. His Kompassmodell would create four geographically redrawn divisions — North, Northeast, West, and Southwest/Bavaria — with club assignments recalculated every year by artificial intelligence.
Resistance began in Bavaria and spread through the south and southwest before the northern associations joined. The NOFV’s break this week, first reported by Sportschau and confirmed to Welt by the German Press Agency (dpa), completed a near-total blockade from the amateur game.
“The core demand ‘champions must be promoted’ would be fulfilled with the 22/5 solution,” the NOFV told Welt. “The five Regionalligas would remain, the Oberligas would remain untouched. Only the 3. Liga would have to change its structure.”
3. Liga clubs vote unanimously against expansion
The 20 professional clubs in the 3. Liga have voted unanimously — 20 to 0 — against expanding to 22 teams, DFB managing director Manuel Hartmann told ARD, according to Welt. “As the operator of the 3. Liga we have a clear mandate: 20 votes for maintaining the current structure and against an expansion to 22 teams. We feel bound by this mandate,” Hartmann said.
The league argues that two additional matchdays would strain squad budgets, increase fixture congestion, and dilute television revenue per club. The DFB executive has backed that position, leaving Neuendorf caught between the amateur base that elects him and the professional league his organization runs.
Procedural fights and financial incentives
The standoff has spilled into procedural maneuvering. Before the last DFB presidium meeting, officials circulated a draft resolution that would have restricted the Bundestag ballot to the Kompassmodell only — a move critics called undemocratic that was withdrawn after pushback.
Süddeutsche Zeitung reported that the DFB also offered delegates a financial incentive: an additional €5–6 million per year for clubs and associations if they approve the Kompassmodell.
Legal questions now loom over the 22/5 proposal. Because expanding the 3. Liga affects Bundesliga and 2. Bundesliga interests — relegation spots and TV money — some DFB officials argue the change requires a two-thirds majority rather than a simple majority. Others contend it falls under amateur competence and needs only 50 percent plus one. The Bundestag’s agenda, which can be manipulated through scheduling, may decide which threshold applies.
Voting math and the risk of stalemate
The Bundestag comprises 257 delegates: 43 from the DFB executive, 74 from Bundesliga and 2. Bundesliga clubs, and 140 from regional and state associations. With the NOFV’s 20-odd votes swinging behind 22/5, and southern and northern associations already opposed to the Kompassmodell, neither proposal appears to have a clear path to the required supermajority.
Tommy Haeder, managing director of Chemnitzer FC and spokesman for the “Champions Must Be Promoted” initiative, told Kicker he considers 22/5 a flawed solution but will vote for it if the Kompassmodell fails. “With the clear note that I don’t find it morally good, but the issue would be resolved in substance for now,” Haeder said.
A pattern of political missteps
The Regionalliga battle is the latest in a string of setbacks for Neuendorf, who took office in March 2022. The women’s Bundesliga broke away to form an independent league company.
The hiring of Marc Kosicke, longtime adviser to Jürgen Klopp, as a DFB consultant triggered transparency questions, according to Sueddeutsche. First vice president Ronny Zimmermann, a Neuendorf ally, lost his reelection as head of the southern regional association. Disputes over the commercialization of player data have persisted.
Neuendorf has scored points on governance issues — notably his public criticism of FIFA president Gianni Infantino — but has yet to translate that into institutional action such as a legal challenge to Infantino’s eligibility.
“Part of Neuendorf’s method is to delay or avoid decisions,” Süddeutsche Zeitung columnist Johannes Aumüller wrote. “On this issue he stayed out for a long time, but eventually had to take a position. And then, for inexplicable reasons, he ruled out the 22/5 solution and embraced the Kompassmodell, clinging to it despite growing resistance.”
What happens on Dec. 18
Delegates can submit motions until Dec. 4. If neither model secures the necessary majority, the status quo remains: five Regionalligas, four promotion spots, and one champion left behind each season — an outcome Aumüller warned “no one could explain anymore.”
Neuendorf, born in Düren in 1961, worked as a parliamentary correspondent in Bonn and deputy editor-in-chief of the Mitteldeutsche Zeitung before entering politics. He served as SPD state manager in North Rhine-Westphalia and, from 2012 to 2017, as state secretary for family, children, youth, culture and sport. In 2019 he became president of the Middle Rhine Football Association, winning election as the 14th DFB president in March 2022 with 193 of 250 votes.
The Bundestag convenes in Frankfurt on Dec. 18.
Worth a look
- Red Sox Acquire Nick Fortes From Rays, Designate Connor Wong for Assignment
- Asturian Referees Gala Honors Promotions, FIFA Official Sara Fernández Ceferino
- European Markets Attempt Rebound Ahead of Anthropic AI Listing (archyde.com)
- Anthropic raises record $107bn ahead of stock market debut (newsarchyuk.com)