“In my view, they don’t have a clue what they are doing,” said Bruce Arena, former United States men’s coach and San Jose Earthquakes manager, on Wednesday regarding U.S. Soccer‘s hunt for a new leader.
The search follows Mauricio Pochettino’s departure on Nov. 13 for Manchester United, ending a tenure that began in September 2024. Pochettino finished on Nov. 17 with a 2-0 victory over Haiti, securing an 8-0 aggregate win in the Concacaf Nations League quarter-finals.
Arena targets a hiring strategy he opposes. When U.S. Soccer hired Pochettino, Arena argued that foreign managers lack an innate grasp of American soccer culture. The federation previously appointed former Germany star and head coach Jurgen Klinsmann under former president Sunil Gulati in 2011 at a salary of $2.5 million per year, an experiment that led to the team failing to qualify for the 2018 World Cup.
“You know if you look at every national team in the world, the coach is usually a domestic coach,” Arena said in 2025 on the “Unfiltered Soccer” podcast with Landon Donovan and Tim Howard.

Arena holds the record as the winningest coach in USMNT history, compiling 81 victories across two stints from 1998 to 2006 and again from 2016 to 2017. During his initial period from 1998 through 2006, he recorded 71 wins, 30 losses, and 29 draws, guiding the Americans to the quarterfinals of the 2002 World Cup.
Pochettino acknowledged facing obstacles due to his nationality. Speaking before his final match, the Argentine manager addressed the skepticism he encountered. Before Pochettino took over from Gregg Berhalter in the fall of 2024, every full-time USMNT head coach over the previous 30 years—with the sole exception of Klinsmann—had been American.
“I didn’t feel the support that I, in my head, (expected),” Pochettino said on Monday, Nov. 16, describing resistance from critics questioning what a foreign coach could teach American soccer and noting how difficult it is to make the sport flourish when it is not the primary sport in the nation.
The search committee includes USWNT head coach Emma Hayes, who defended her advisory role, offering her technical lens and experience from a 25-year career that includes winning the Women’s Super League with Chelsea and guiding the U.S. women’s team to an Olympic gold medal.

“I feel confident in the group of people that have been put together to create a thorough process to select the next men’s national team coach,” Hayes said on Wednesday.
Arena, born in Brooklyn in 1951, earned his only U.S. national team cap as a substitute against Israel in 1973 and also played for the national lacrosse team that won the 1974 World Lacrosse Championship. Before his professional coaching career, he was drafted by the New York Cosmos but released before the season, then spent a year with the Montreal Quebecois in the National Lacrosse League before it folded.
San Jose faces Houston in the opening match of the MLS playoffs under Arena, who said that playing Houston twice during the year means there will be no surprises in the best-of-three series, while U.S. Soccer continues its search for Pochettino’s successor ahead of the December friendly against Jamaica.