“The baseball is for too everyone, and the Blue Jays have created an inclusive environment in which all supporters feel welcome in our stadium,” the club said.
Toronto Blue Jays outfielder Anthony Santander faced widespread criticism after sharing anti-Muslim social media posts on his Instagram account following the United States midterm elections on November 3, 2026.
The shared content included a video claiming that the election of Abdul El-Sayed to the United States Senate in Michigan would lead to the implementation of Sharia law. Another video featured a Christian preacher asserting that no benevolent Muslims exist.
“We were surprised to discover that a professional player, and particularly a member of a team that we support, shared such messages,” said Abdul Murad, head of a Muslim softball league in the Toronto area.
Santander deleted the posts two days after publishing them. He did not issue an immediate public apology.
The National Council of Canadian Muslims called the situation concerning while expressing hope for constructive dialogue. Steven Zhou, media relations and communications coordinator for the organization, outlined the community’s position.
“Many members of the community want first of all to obtain an apology from the player and to see more constructive relations established,” Zhou said.
Zhou added that the organization remains open to meeting with team officials and Santander to foster better understanding.
Toronto general manager Ross Atkins addressed the controversy on November 10 during a meeting of Major League Baseball executives in Las Vegas. Atkins called the posts deeply disappointing and concerning.
Atkins said that he personally expressed his disappointment to Santander and asked the player to address the matter publicly. The executive emphasized the unique visibility and influence professional athletes hold.
As of November 11, Santander had not released a public explanation or apology.
Worth a look
