Big Ten Playoff Hopes Collapse After Three Ranked Teams Fall

Big Ten playoff hopes collapsed in Week 12 after UCLA, Indiana and Ohio State all lost, leaving the conference facing the possibility of a single berth in the 12-team field.

Three ranked Big Ten teams fell on Saturday, a slate of results that USA Today described as a “doomsday scenario” for a conference that entered the weekend expecting multiple playoff bids. No. 4 UCLA lost in triple overtime to Michigan, No. 8 Indiana fell in overtime at Washington and No. 14 Ohio State dropped a 31-28 decision at Nebraska, snapping the Huskers’ 31-game winless streak against ranked opponents.

The conference champion is guaranteed a spot in the tournament.

This weekend was supposed to bring clarity to a topsy-turvy race. Oregon has three losses.

Nebraska STUNS No. 14 Ohio State to crush Buckeyes CFP hopes, snaps losing streak vs AP-Ranked teams — CBS Sports

UCLA quarterback injury clouds Bruins outlook

The most consequential moment for the Bruins came on the first play of overtime, when quarterback Ty Dieffenbach was tackled, stayed down and was carted off the field on a stretcher. Third-string quarterback Madden Iamaleava replaced him and struggled to move the offense, leading to a pair of field goals and a failed two-point conversion in the third overtime.

Iamaleava, whose brother Nico suffered a season-ending knee injury earlier in the year, is in line to start against No. 18 USC in Week 13 if Dieffenbach cannot play, Yahoo Sports reported. The CFB Playoff selection committee might take that into account in Tuesday’s rankings. That might drop the Bruins an additional spot or two.

Big Ten Playoff Hopes Collapse After Three Ranked Teams Fall
Photo: CBS Sports

USA Today noted the committee could evaluate UCLA the way it assessed Florida State in 2023, when an unbeaten team was dropped after losing its starting quarterback. The Bruins are still expected to remain in Tuesday’s provisional playoff rankings, but a loss to the Trojans with a backup under center could push them out of the at-large picture entirely.

For now, UCLA should stay in the provisional College Football Playoff field in Tuesday’s rankings. A win over USC likely confirms UCLA’s spot in the 12-team playoff field as well.

Indiana and Ohio State slide toward elimination

Indiana’s loss ended the Hoosiers’ hopes of repeating as Big Ten champions and left them with two defeats for the first time under coach Curt Cignetti. The Hoosiers rotated quarterbacks, inserting former starter Josh Hoover for Grant Wilson, but were outscored 13-10 after the change.

CBS Sports reported Indiana owns just one ranked win — against USC — and its opponents are 23-33 against Power Four competition, a profile that could drop the Hoosiers to the edge of the bubble.

The Hoosiers end November against Purdue. Is the Big Ten a one-bid playoff league? At this point, even getting a pair into the 12-team field will take some work. The Hoosiers could be on the wrong side of the tiebreaker, too. All three teams beat Northwestern and Michigan. Iowa beat Washington. And Oregon has Washington next week.

Ohio State fell to 7-4, its most losses in a season since 2011, and has no path to an at-large berth. The Buckeyes managed only 76 rushing yards on 22 carries while allowing Nebraska 176 on the ground.

College football winners and losers: Big Ten’s dismal day could doom conference’s playoff hopes
Photo: dailyvoxa.com

But on third-and-five, Anthony Colandrea got six to run out the clock.

With Oregon at three losses and Iowa at two but lacking signature wins, the Big Ten’s playoff hopes rest on UCLA beating USC to reach the conference title game.

The Big Ten will also be hoping that Utah closes strong and doesn’t lose the Big 12 title game to Texas Tech or BYU, and that Wake Forest can upset Miami in the ACC and Notre Dame suffers a second loss to keep the at-large pool from crowding out the Big Ten champion.

Founded in 1896 as the Intercollegiate Conference of Faculty Representatives, the Big Ten is the oldest NCAA Division I conference, predating the NCAA itself. For decades it comprised ten Midwestern universities, but a 2024 expansion added four former Pac-12 schools — including UCLA and USC — extending its footprint to the West Coast and raising membership to 18 full institutions.

The next CFP rankings release is scheduled for Tuesday, November 24.

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archysport.