Automated Checked-Swing Reviews Introduced in Minor Leagues

Batters gained a clear advantage in minor league checked-swing reviews this season as technology stepped in to assist umpires with notoriously difficult bang-bang calls, according to data examined by ESPN Deportes.

Major League pitchers continue dialing up velocity, turning routine contact into an increasingly difficult task for hitters across professional baseball. That overarching trend has driven strikeup rates steadily upward over the last two decades, climbing from 16.4% of plate appearances in 2006 to 23.9% last season, before hitting a peak of 27% in 2022 prior to the implementation of the pitch clock.

Mike Hazen, gerente general de los Arizona Diamondbacks, expresó sobre el tema: “Creo que me gusta”. A esto añadió: “No me parece que el proceso actual para determinar un swing contenido sea el ideal; de hecho, parece ser una fuente de frustración para los jugadores”.

“I think I like it”, Arizona Diamondbacks general manager Mike Hazen told ESPN Deportes, adding that the current process for determining a checked swing is far from ideal and serves as a constant source of frustration.

Hitters Succeed in Overturning Checked Swings

The Pacific Coast League at the Triple-A level introduced an automated challenge system for checked swings starting May 5. Hitters requested reviews an average of 0.25 times per game during the trial, achieving a success rate of 55.5% in overturning original umpire rulings.

That technological intervention triggered a measurable shift in offensive production against non-fastballs. Whiff rates dropped across multiple pitch categories following the May 5 implementation date in the Pacific Coast League compared to the same period in previous action.

Pitch Type Whiff Rate Change
Breaking balls (curves, sliders, sweepers, knuckleballs) Down 2.6 percentage points
Off-speed pitches (changeups, splitters, screwballs) Down 3.6 percentage points
Fastballs (four-seamers, sinkers, cutters) 19.3% (compared to 19.4% previously)

Defining the Checked Swing Under Review

Official baseball rules have long avoided a precise mathematical definition for checked swings, stating simply that a strike is a legal pitch declared by the umpire when a batter attempts a swing and misses. The Automated Ball-Strike Challenge System trial filled that void by defining a swing as any instance where the maximum angle between the bat head and handle surpasses 45 degrees, aligning with the foul lines.

Not everyone agrees that giving hitters more leeway on checked swings is beneficial for the game. Milwaukee Brewers manager Pat Murphy pointed to a controversial checked swing by Yandy Díaz of the Tampa Bay Rays that ended Game 2 of the World Series, noting that slow-motion replay showed the thick part of the bat had clearly crossed the front of home plate.

“Según lo que vi anoche, pensé: ‘No, no hizo el swing’”, comentó Murphy al día siguiente. “Pero, al ver la imagen en cámara lenta, efectivamente, la parte gruesa del bate estaba por delante”.

Los Angeles Dodgers general manager Brandon Gomes suggested that the 45-degree threshold might need slight adjustments to prevent hitters from getting away with full motions reminiscent of historical pitching footage.

“Quizás sea necesaria una ligera modificación”, señaló Gomes, “porque, si el bate llega tan lejos, ocurre algo parecido a lo que se ve en algunos videos antiguos de Sandy Koufax: el bateador realiza un swing completo y uno se pregunta: ‘¿De verdad logró detener el swing?'”.

Future Timeline for Major League Adoption

Testing for the automated checked-swing technology began in the Arizona Fall League in 2024 before expanding to the Class-A Florida State League in 2025. Major League Baseball Commissioner Rob Manfred indicated that if the system eventually reaches the major leagues, it will not happen before 2028.

New York Yankees starting pitcher Gerrit Cole emphasized the need to stabilize things following recent changes.

“Hemos realizado muchos cambios en los últimos cinco años y, en mi opinión, es momento de estabilizar un poco las cosas”, manifestó el serpentinero de los New York Yankees y galardonado con el premio Cy Young de la Liga Americana en 2023, tal como lo dio a conocer ESPN Deportes.

“La situación actual con el ABS ha funcionado realmente bien; así que, mejor no estropeemos algo que ya funciona correctamente”.

football Desk

football Desk at Archysport.