Kylian Mbappe faces persistent questions over his defensive contribution at Real Madrid, but teammate Antonio Ruediger dismissed the notion that the prolific forward should track back like a defender, according to Demokratis.
Mbappe has scored 103 goals since joining Los Blancos ahead of the 2024/2025 season, though the club has yet to secure a domestic league title during that span, according to figures cited by detikSport. That heavy goal-scoring burden is precisely why Ruediger believes asking the French international to shoulder defensive responsibilities makes no sense.
“Apakah saya benar-benar harus meminta seorang pemain yang telah mencetak 100 gol dalam dua tahun untuk melakukan pekerjaan saya? Itu tidak masuk akal,” kata Ruediger, as reported by detikSport.
The debate over how much defensive ground forwards should cover has shadowed Madrid throughout the campaign. While analysts and supporters occasionally question Mbappe’s work rate off the ball, Ruediger’s comments offer a stark look inside the dressing room’s division of labor.
Ruediger, who has made 189 appearances for the club, pointed directly to Madrid’s historical blueprint for success in his interview with The Athletic. He argued that legendary forwards of the past were never subjected to strict defensive mandates.
“Apa yang terjadi ketika Gareth Bale, Benzema, dan Cristiano Ronaldo bermain? Tidak ada yang mengatakan mereka harus bertahan, dan lihatlah kesuksesan yang mereka raih. Ego di ruang ganti? Itu adalah sejarah Real Madrid,” Ruediger menjelaskan, according to detikSport.
Demokratis.co.id said that Ruediger compared Mbappe’s current situation directly to the expectations placed upon Gareth Bale, Karim Benzema, and Cristiano Ronaldo during their respective stints at the Santiago Bernabeu, according to sepakbola. None of those attacking icons were heavily burdened with defensive duties, leaving the dirty work to the midfield and backline.
Beyond tactical roles on the pitch, Ruediger addressed the unique pressure cooker of the Real Madrid locker room, where elite egos and high-profile signings are a constant feature of club life.
“Orang-orang seperti Lopetegui atau Benítez memiliki masalah karena klub ini selalu memiliki banyak bintang, kepribadian hebat dalam sepakbola. Itu bukan mitos, itu kenyataan,” Ruediger tegasnya, as reported by detikSport.
That reality, according to the German center-back, requires coaches to accommodate star players rather than force them into unnatural tactical molds. Managing elite personalities has derailed previous managerial tenures in the Spanish capital, yet Ruediger views it simply as the historic identity of the club.
While Mbappe’s individual numbers remain staggering at 103 goals since arriving in 2024, the absence of a domestic league trophy remains a glaring talking point in Spanish football media. DetikSport and SuaraGarut.ID both highlighted the paradox of a player delivering historic scoring figures while his team continues to chase domestic supremacy.
Keep reading