Why Kylian Mbappé Failed to Win the Ballon d'Or: The Price of Being "The Chosen One

Kylian Mbappé finished outside the top contenders for the 2025 Ballon d’Or, with the award going to Harry Kane at the London Palladium on Monday, October 26. Despite a season defined by high-volume scoring, the Real Madrid forward saw his candidacy undermined by a lack of major collective trophies, a shift in voting criteria, and a series of controversies that have complicated his public standing.

The Statistical Ceiling at Real Madrid

Mbappé’s season statistics were prolific on an individual level, totaling 58 goals and 13 assists across 60 matches. However, these figures failed to secure the top prize, as voters prioritized collective achievements and fair play. Throughout the campaign, the captain of the French national team failed to capture a major title, including the Champions League or a domestic league crown, leaving his individual records as the primary argument for his selection. The absence of team success highlighted the limitations of relying solely on personal output in the current voting framework.

From Prodigy to Polarizing Figure

The narrative surrounding Mbappé has shifted significantly since his breakout year in 2018, when he helped France win the World Cup at age 19. Early in his career, his confidence and communication were viewed as signs of precocious maturity. Over time, these same traits have been interpreted by critics as arrogance. His appointment as captain of the French national team in March 2023, replacing Antoine Griezmann, served to further polarize supporters who were already divided by his performance at Euro 2021 and his high-profile friction with Paris Saint-Germain leadership.

The Legal Dispute with Paris Saint-Germain

The relationship between the player and his former club reached a definitive breaking point in court. In December 2025, the Paris labor court (prud’hommes) ruled in favor of Mbappé in a dispute over 55 million euros in unpaid wages and bonuses. While the legal victory solidified his financial position, the public nature of the proceedings—viewed by many supporters as a cold, transactional conclusion to his time at the Parc des Princes—damaged his image. The transition to Real Madrid has not yet provided the expected buffer, as the club’s lack of silverware and his off-field activities have been scrutinized by a demanding section of the Bernabeu.

The Challenge of the New Generation

Mbappé’s career trajectory has influenced a new wave of French athletes, including Victor Wembanyama in basketball, Paul Seixas in cycling, the Lebrun brothers in table tennis, and Désiré Doué. While these younger stars have adopted his unapologetic ambition, they have largely avoided the public friction that has defined Mbappé’s recent years. Observers note that while the “Mbappé project”—characterized by high expectations and protective management—opened doors for this generation, the younger athletes have generally succeeded in balancing individual goals with team dynamics, a balance that Mbappé has struggled to maintain in the eyes of his critics.

The Unresolved Ambition

At 27 years old, Mbappé remains an elite talent, yet he faces increasing pressure to reconcile his personal brand with the realities of team sports. His assertion to France Football that he was always viewed as “the chosen one” rather than just a “talented player” reportedly caused friction among his peers, including his friend Ousmane Dembélé. Whether he can recalibrate his approach to the collective remains the central, unresolved question as he continues his tenure in Madrid. The Ballon d’Or ceremony confirmed that for another year, the forward remains defined as much by his own myth as by his performance on the pitch.

Worth a look