German Football Association president Bernd Neuendorf faced swift resistance from regional federation leaders on Monday after presenting his proposed overhaul for the country’s lower divisions.
Compass Model Reorganizes Regional Leagues to Resolve Promotion Flaws
At the center of the dispute is Neuendorf’s proposed “compass model,” designed to resolve a long-standing structural flaw in German football where only four of the five regional league champions secure automatic promotion to the professional 3rd Liga. The plan reorganizes the existing five regional divisions into four larger leagues of 20 teams each, eliminating rigid state borders in favor of yearly geographic adjustments aimed at minimizing travel distances. Participants at Monday’s meeting criticized the vague criteria for protecting traditional local derbies, warning that arbitrary administrative decisions could easily spark widespread unfairness. Regional officials from Hesse highlighted a particularly disruptive outcome that would scatter local clubs across all four newly minted divisions.
Critics also cautioned that the geographical distribution of clubs could destabilize regional roots over time, pointing to the current 3rd Liga as a cautionary tale where eight federal states lack any representation and a vast competitive vacuum spans central Germany. Shifting operational control from the regional associations directly to the DFB further complicates the transition, raising unresolved questions regarding employment law and staff relocations for personnel currently managing regional league operations.
Divided Delegations and Tight Margins Threaten the December Vote
Neuendorf must secure a two-thirds majority among the 257 delegates at an extraordinary federal congress scheduled for December 18 to enact the reform. The voting body comprises amateur representatives from the regional associations—including 51 from the south, 29 from the west, 24 from the north, 22 from the northeast, and 14 from the southwest—alongside 74 votes from professional clubs and 43 members of the DFB executive board. Opposition runs particularly high in the southern and southwestern regional associations, where combined amateur delegates approach, though do not quite reach, a blocking minority. Professional clubs hold a crucial swing vote, though their internal priorities remain fragmented depending on league tier and regional origin.
Counterproposals Ahead of Friday Executive Meeting
Bayern football chief Christoph Kern announced plans to introduce an alternative counterproposal known as the 22/5 model, which would expand the 3rd Liga to 22 teams and introduce a fifth relegation spot to preserve the five existing regional divisions. The immediate test for Neuendorf arrives on Friday during the upcoming DFB executive committee meeting, where leadership traditionally introduces motions unanimously. With several regional chiefs from the critical southern and southwestern factions sitting on the 17-member committee, unanimous backing appears far from guaranteed before the formal proposals go to the December congress.
Worth a look
