White Sox Weigh Top Prospects: Emerson, Cholowsky, Lackey for No. 1 Draft Pick

The Case for Grady Emerson and the High School Ceiling

Grady Emerson, a shortstop from Fort Worth Christian High School in Texas, enters the draft as the top-ranked prospect on the MLB Pipeline list. He is widely regarded as the best pure hitter in the 2026 class. According to MLB.com, Emerson possesses above-average tools across the board and could potentially earn 60 or higher grades for hitting, power, arm, and defense. The appeal of Emerson lies in his ceiling. Analysts suggest that if he had chosen the college route, he might be a better prospect than Roch Cholowsky is currently. FanGraphs notes that there are few questions regarding Emerson’s swing, suggesting it is unlikely he will struggle with high strikeout rates in professional ball. However, the risk is the timeline. Because he is coming directly from high school, the perception is that he will take longer to reach the major leagues. While he has raw power, it hasn’t consistently translated to game production yet. For the White Sox, taking Emerson is a bet on the highest possible peak at the cost of immediate reliability.

Roch Cholowsky: The Polished UCLA Product

Roch Cholowsky represents the opposite profile to Emerson. A shortstop at UCLA, Cholowsky has spent three years refining his game on the top college team in the country. His production is documented: 44 home runs and 134 runs batted in over the last two seasons, with a combined OPS around 1.100, as reported by MLB.com. His sophomore year was particularly dominant. According to The New York Times, Cholowsky hit .353/.480/.710 with a 60 percent hard-hit rate and a strikeout rate below 10 percent. Despite these numbers, some scouts have raised questions. FanGraphs mentions concerns regarding whether his swing will translate to professional pitching and how he performs with a wood bat. While he is a natural leader with a high floor, his junior season was slightly below his sophomore peak, leading some to wonder if he has already hit his ceiling.

Vahn Lackey as the Contingency Plan

While Emerson and Cholowsky are the primary contenders for the top spot, Georgia Tech catcher Vahn Lackey remains in the conversation. Lackey is coming off one of the most productive offensive seasons in college baseball, posting a 1.291 OPS with 20 home runs and 15 steals, according to MLB.com. Lackey is viewed more as a contingency for the White Sox, but he is a primary target for other teams. FanGraphs mocks Lackey to the Tampa Bay Rays at No. 2, citing the Rays’ long-term need for a catcher who can defend and throw at a high level.

Comparing the Top Three Candidates

The divide between the candidates comes down to a choice between raw potential and proven collegiate performance.

Player	Position/School	Primary Strength	Primary Risk
Grady Emerson	SS / Fort Worth Christian	Highest ceiling; best pure hitter	Longer path to MLB; high school raw power
Roch Cholowsky	SS / UCLA	Proven collegiate production; high floor	Questions on wood bat/pro swing transition
Vahn Lackey	C / Georgia Tech	Elite 2026 college offensive stats	Viewed as a contingency for the No. 1 pick

Draft Odds and Market Sentiment

The industry is split on who the White Sox will ultimately select. On the MLB Pipeline Podcast, Jim Callis and others assigned specific odds to the candidates. Callis placed Emerson at 51% and Cholowsky at 47%, while Lackey sat at 2%. Other analysts, such as Mayo, put Emerson and Cholowsky at an even 50-50 split, according to MLB.com. The broader quality of the 2026 class is a point of contention. The New York Times describes it as “not a great class,” noting a lack of high-end pitching and a group of college position players that didn’t fully pan out. This makes the decision at No. 1 even more critical, as the talent pool is expected to drop off quickly after the top five players. For the White Sox, the decision is a strategic pivot. They previously attempted to sign Cholowsky out of high school, confirming their long-term interest in the shortstop, according to FanGraphs. The draft’s first round will be broadcast across several platforms. Picks 1-10 will air on NBC and Peacock, while picks 11-40 and beyond will be available on MLB Network and MLB’s digital platforms. The White Sox will reveal their choice shortly after 1 p.m. ET this Saturday. While some portions of draft ranking sites may currently appear “under construction” as final ordinal rankings are folded in, the focus remains on whether Chicago opts for the high-school ceiling of Emerson or the collegiate stability of Cholowsky.

Find more reporting in our Sport news section.