The golden age of French intellectuals is definitively over, according to Robert Zaretsky, a professor of history at the University of Houston’s Honors College. Writing in Foreign Policy, Zaretsky argues that modern thinkers have shifted away from cerebral engagement toward mere celebrity, losing the profound political influence once held by figures like Voltaire and Émile Zola.
The Power of the Republic of Letters
Historically, French intellectuals commanded an international audience and directly shaped public policy. Voltaire mastered the art of addressing multiple publics simultaneously, bridging the international “Republic of Letters” with the royal court. During the Affaire Calas, Voltaire mobilized public opinion, wrote treatises, and successfully rehabilitated the memory of Protestant merchant Jean Calas. Decades later, the Dreyfus Affair marked the absolute zenith of this tradition. Émile Zola published his famous “J’accuse” in the pages of L’Aurore in 1898, reaching millions of readers worldwide and forcing a national reckoning.
Existentialists and the Spirit of Voltaire
That sweeping authority began to fragment during the interwar period, accelerated by political polarization over Soviet Russia. While mid-century existentialists like Jean-Paul Sartre, Simone de Beauvoir, and Albert Camus briefly revived the archetype—prompting Charles de Gaulle to reportedly decline arresting Sartre in 1968 by stating, “On n’arrête pas Voltaire.”—subsequent decades eroded that standing. The rise of television forced complex arguments into brief soundbites on programs like Apostrophes, while media fragmentation diluted the collective voice of the nation’s thinkers.
Marginalized by Algorithms and Modern Protest
Modern socio-political flashpoints no longer yield guiding intellectual voices. During the “Gilets jaunes” (Yellow Vests) protests, contemporary thinkers were relegated to passive observers rather than catalysts for change. Structural factors, from the fall of the Berlin Wall to the rise of algorithmic social media feeds, have rendered the traditional public intellectual largely marginal. While current commentators still publish opinion columns in outlets like L’Express and Le Monde, their reach and impact remain fractional compared to their historical predecessors, signaling the transition into what Zaretsky characterizes as the intellectual autumn preceding an inevitable winter.
Worth a look
