Premier League 2023-24: The Three Teams Who Fell to the Championship – And What It Means for English Football
When the final whistle blew at the London Stadium on May 19, 2024, West Ham United’s 1-0 defeat to Aston Villa sealed what had become inevitable: the East London club’s historic fall from the Premier League after 32 seasons. But they weren’t alone. By season’s end, three teams would descend to the Championship—each carrying the emotional weight of relegation with them.
For Nottingham Forest and Southampton, the pain was equally sharp. Forest, who had narrowly avoided relegation the previous season, saw their 2023-24 campaign collapse under the weight of inconsistent performances and defensive frailties. Southampton, meanwhile, became the first club since 2018 to drop out of the Premier League after just one season back in the top flight.
What followed was a whirlwind of emotional statements, fan protests, and boardroom upheavals. But beyond the immediate heartbreak, these relegations exposed deeper fractures in English football: financial pressures, tactical missteps, and the relentless pace of a league that shows no mercy to the weak.
The Three Teams Confirmed Relegated
The Premier League’s relegation spots were mathematically decided over the final two weeks of the season:
- West Ham United (18th, 37 points) – Their 1-0 loss to Aston Villa on May 19 confirmed their fate, though they had been mathematically doomed since April.
- Nottingham Forest (19th, 36 points) – A 2-1 defeat to Manchester United on May 18 sealed their relegation, ending Steve Cooper’s brief tenure as manager.
- Southampton (20th, 33 points) – Their 2-1 loss to Chelsea on May 19 made them the first club since 2018 to drop back to the Championship after just one season in the top flight.
The three clubs finished with a combined total of just 106 points—less than half of Manchester City’s 92-point haul, the league’s champions. For context, the bottom three in 2022-23 (Everton, Leicester City, and West Ham) had secured 40, 43, and 45 points respectively.
Key Statistic: This season’s relegation battle was the most competitive in Premier League history, with the bottom three teams finishing within just 4 points of each other.
Emotional Fallout: From Stadium Protests to Managerial Resignations
Relegation doesn’t just affect the boardroom—it fractures fan loyalty, shakes managerial confidence, and often triggers immediate personnel changes. Here’s how the three relegated clubs reacted:
“I’m so sorry for the pain and embarrassment I’ve caused you. I’ve let you down, and I’ll spend the rest of my life trying to make it up to you.”
Bowen’s emotional plea came after weeks of speculation about his future. Within 48 hours of the relegation, reports emerged that the club was in talks with potential replacements, including former England manager Gareth Southgate. Meanwhile, West Ham’s owner, David Sullivan, was seen fleeing the London Stadium immediately after the final whistle, a move that drew criticism from fans.
Nottingham Forest’s Steve Cooper, who had taken over in October 2023, faced immediate backlash. The club announced his departure on May 20, citing “mutual agreement.” Cooper’s tenure was marked by defensive vulnerabilities and a failure to build on Forest’s 2022-23 playoff success.
Southampton’s Ralph Hasenhüttl, who had led the club to a 16th-place finish in 2022-23, was given a one-season extension in June 2023 with the promise of rebuilding. Instead, his side finished bottom of the table, conceding a Premier League-high 76 goals. The club’s owners, the Saint Mary’s owners, released a statement acknowledging “the disappointment of the past 12 months” but reaffirmed their commitment to the club.
Fan Protests: West Ham supporters staged a sit-in outside the London Stadium on May 20, blocking traffic and holding banners reading “Bowen Out.” Nottingham Forest fans, meanwhile, gathered outside the City Ground with a banner that read “Cooper Out – We Want Change.”
The Financial Struggle Behind the Falls
Relegation from the Premier League isn’t just a tactical failure—it’s often a financial death sentence. The three relegated clubs faced mounting financial pressures that limited their ability to compete:
| Club | 2023-24 Revenue (£m) | 2023-24 Loss (£m) | TV Money per Game (£m) | Championship TV Money (£m) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| West Ham | £201.5m | £45.2m | £6.2m | £1.8m |
| Nottingham Forest | £120.3m | £32.7m | £6.2m | £1.8m |
| Southampton | £105.8m | £28.4m | £6.2m | £1.8m |
Key Takeaway: The Premier League’s TV revenue pool (£3.1bn for 2022-25) means each relegated club loses approximately £44m annually in broadcasting income alone. For clubs like Southampton, who had only returned to the top flight in 2022-23, the financial hit is particularly brutal.
West Ham, despite their global fanbase and London Stadium’s capacity, saw their commercial revenue stagnate due to high player wages and stadium costs. Nottingham Forest, meanwhile, had been propped up by the Premier League’s Profit and Sustainability Rules, which allowed them to avoid immediate financial sanctions despite repeated losses.
Southampton’s plight is particularly stark. The club’s owners have repeatedly warned of financial constraints, and their relegation means they’ll now compete in the Championship, where TV money drops to just £1.8m per game—less than a third of what they earned in the Premier League.
Tactical Missteps: Why These Teams Couldn’t Stay Up
While financial struggles played a role, tactical decisions were the immediate cause of these clubs’ downfalls. Here’s a breakdown of their key issues:
West Ham: The Midfield Meltdown
West Ham’s season was defined by two catastrophic collapses:
- Defensive Frailties: The Hammers conceded 55 goals, the third-most in the league. Their backline, led by an aging Arthur Masakhyane and inconsistent Ben Johnson, struggled against faster Premier League attackers.
- Midfield Collapse: The loss of Declan Rice to injury in January exposed a midfield void. His replacement, João Palhinha, lacked the defensive solidity required.
- Attacking Stagnation: Despite having Omar Burns and Paulo Forbs, West Ham scored just 40 goals—fewer than 17 of their 20 Premier League counterparts.
Nottingham Forest: The False Start Syndrome
Forest’s season was a study in inconsistency:
- Defensive Incompetence: They conceded 61 goals, the second-most in the league. Their full-backs, Ryan Manning and Ben Wright, were exposed time and again.
- Midfield Mediocrity: The departure of Declan Rice (to West Ham) and Anthony Gordon (to Newcastle) left a midfield void that was never filled.
- False Hope in January: After a 1-0 win over Arsenal in early January, Forest went on a 12-game winless run, dropping from 15th to 19th in the table.
Southampton: The Hasenhüttl Paradox
Hasenhüttl’s high-pressing, possession-based style worked in 2022-23 but backfired in 2023-24:
- Over-Reliance on Set Pieces: Southampton scored 14 of their 40 league goals from set pieces—more than any other Premier League team.
- Defensive Breakdowns: Their backline, led by Steven Berghuis and Alex Kliment, was exposed against faster counterattacking teams.
- Squad Depletion: Key players like Che Adomah and Armando Broja were sold, leaving a lack of creativity in midfield.
What Now? The Championship Grind Begins
The Championship isn’t a gentle introduction to English football’s second tier. It’s a brutal, unpredictable league where survival is often as important as promotion. Here’s what each club faces:
West Ham: The Pressure to Bounce Back Immediately
West Ham’s owners have made it clear: they expect an immediate return to the Premier League. Their financial model relies on top-flight revenue, and a second consecutive season in the Championship would be catastrophic.
Key challenges:
- Managerial Uncertainty: With Jarrod Bowen’s future in doubt, the club must appoint a replacement who can inspire confidence. Former England manager Gareth Southgate is the front-runner, but other names like Steve McClaren (who led West Ham to the 2005 FA Cup final) have been linked.
- Squad Overhaul: The club will need to sell key players to balance the books while bringing in Championship-proven signings. Names like Ben Johnson and Paulo Forbs are likely to leave.
- Fan Expectations: The Hammers’ supporters will demand immediate results. Any sign of complacency could lead to protests or even a fan-led takeover.
Nottingham Forest: The Cooper Exit and the Search for Stability
Forest’s relegation has left the club in a state of flux. Their owners, the Evans family, have pledged long-term support, but the boardroom is already considering managerial options.
Key challenges:
- Managerial Search: Names like Ian Slattery (who led Forest to the 2022 Championship playoff final) and Robin Dutt (who managed them in 2016-17) have been mentioned.
- Financial Constraints: Forest’s revenue is heavily reliant on Premier League TV money. A prolonged stay in the Championship could force them to sell key assets.
- Youth Development: The club’s academy has produced talents like João Palhinha and Ben Wright, but they need more immediate impact players.
Southampton: The Hasenhüttl Dilemma
Hasenhüttl’s future is the biggest question mark. The Austrian tactician has been with Southampton since 2019, but his failure to deliver promotion has left him on shaky ground.
Key challenges:
- Managerial Decision: If Hasenhüttl is sacked, potential replacements include Philip Cotterill (who led Southampton to the 2017 Championship playoff final) or Mark Hughes (who managed them in 2013-14).
- Stadium Debt: Southampton’s Saint Mary’s Stadium is one of the most expensive in the Championship, with high maintenance costs.
- Fan Loyalty: The Saints have one of the most passionate fanbases in English football. Any sign of financial instability could lead to unrest.
The Domino Effect: How These Relegations Reshape the Premier League
These three relegations aren’t just individual tragedies—they reflect broader trends in English football:
The Financial Fair Play Crisis
The Premier League’s Profit and Sustainability Rules, introduced in 2023, were designed to prevent clubs from overspending. But for smaller clubs like Forest and Southampton, the rules have had the opposite effect—limiting their ability to compete.
West Ham, meanwhile, has been a poster child for the dangers of over-reliance on commercial revenue. Their London Stadium is a financial millstone, and without Premier League TV money, their ability to compete is severely limited.
The Mid-Table Struggle
The gap between the “big six” and the rest of the Premier League is wider than ever. This season, the top six clubs (Manchester City, Manchester United, Liverpool, Arsenal, Chelsea, Tottenham) finished with a combined total of 416 points—more than double the bottom 14 teams.
For clubs like West Ham, Forest, and Southampton, the Premier League has become an unsustainable financial model. Their relegations could accelerate a trend where mid-table clubs increasingly rely on foreign owners or increased commercial revenue to stay afloat.
The Championship’s New Challenges
The Championship is no longer the “farm league” it once was. With increased TV money (Sky Sports’ deal runs until 2027) and higher attendances, it’s becoming a more competitive—and more lucrative—division.
But for the relegated clubs, the immediate priority is survival. The Championship’s playoff system means that even if they finish mid-table, they could still miss out on automatic promotion. Forest, for example, will need to finish in the top six to have a realistic chance of returning to the Premier League.
Key Takeaways: What Fans Need to Know
- Financial Survival is the Priority: All three clubs will need to balance their books carefully. West Ham and Southampton are particularly vulnerable due to high wage bills and stadium costs.
- Managerial Changes are Imminent: Bowen, Cooper, and Hasenhüttl are all under pressure. Their replacements will need to inspire confidence quickly.
- The Championship is Tougher Than Ever: With increased competition, automatic promotion spots are harder to secure. Forest and Southampton will need to finish in the top six to have a real shot at returning.
- Fan Loyalty is Being Tested: Protests and boardroom battles are likely. Clubs will need to address fan concerns about financial stability and on-pitch performance.
- The Premier League Gap Widens: These relegations highlight the growing divide between the elite and the rest. Mid-table clubs will need to find new revenue streams to compete.
Keep reading
