Just five minutes into the LaLiga clash between Real Betis and Real Madrid at Estadio Benito Villamarín on April 24, 2026, the first major controversy of the match erupted. Real Betis players and fans immediately appealed for a penalty after a challenge involving Brahim Díaz inside the penalty area, claiming the ball struck his shoulder or arm.
The incident occurred when Brahim attempted to control a loose ball near the six-yard box. Replays showed contact between the ball and what appeared to be his upper body, prompting vigorous protests from the Betis bench and supporters in the stands. The home crowd at La Cartuja stadium voiced their displeasure, demanding referee César Soto Grado consult the VAR.
According to match officials, VAR official González Fuertes reviewed the incident and determined no penalty should be awarded. The decision was communicated to the 22 players on the field, stating there was no punishable handball offense. Despite the protests, play continued without interruption.
But, subsequent analysis of the broadcast footage has left room for debate. Critics noted the lack of a clear, ideal camera angle made it difficult to definitively confirm whether the ball made contact with Brahim’s shoulder or arm. The available replays did not clearly show the point of impact, fueling ongoing discussion among pundits and fans about whether the correct call was made.
The controversy added to the intense atmosphere of the Seville derby, a fixture historically marked by tight officiating decisions and passionate reactions from both sets of supporters. Early in the match, the incident set a tense tone that would persist throughout the 90 minutes.
As the game progressed, both teams created chances, but the early handball appeal remained a talking point in post-match analysis. The decision not to award a penalty was consistent with the VAR protocol in place for the 2025-26 LaLiga season, which requires clear and obvious evidence to overturn an on-field decision.
Looking ahead, Real Madrid prepared for their next fixture against Villarreal, while Real Betis turned their focus to their upcoming match against Athletic Club. The handball incident, while not altering the immediate outcome, contributed to the broader conversation about VAR effectiveness and consistency in high-stakes matches.
What do you think about the referee’s decision? Share your thoughts in the comments below and join the discussion on social media.
