MUNICH – The question of who steps up to take a penalty for Bayern Munich should Harry Kane be unavailable has recently surfaced, revealing a surprisingly relaxed approach to set-piece hierarchy within the Bavarian powerhouse. Whereas Kane has taken all 16 penalties this season, converting 14, the club’s internal discussions highlight a flexible system where the decision isn’t predetermined, but rather a “feeling” decided in the moment by manager Vincent Kompany. This evolving dynamic reflects a broader shift in how Bayern approaches tactical details, even as they chase silverware on multiple fronts.
The discussion arose following a recent game where the possibility of a penalty taker beyond Kane was considered. Serge Gnabry was the last player to convert a penalty for Bayern in the Bundesliga, doing so against Bochum last season. However, Kompany indicated that several players are potential candidates, including Joshua Kimmich, Jamal Musiala, Nicolas Jackson, and Tom Bischof. The ultimate decision, he stated, would be based on the player who “feels” most confident in the moment.
This seemingly casual approach contrasts with the increasingly choreographed nature of modern football, where set pieces and even kickoffs are meticulously planned. Bayern, however, appears comfortable with a degree of spontaneity, particularly when it comes to penalty taking. It’s a testament to the trust Kompany has placed in his squad and their ability to make quick decisions under pressure.
The emergence of Musiala as a potential penalty taker is particularly noteworthy. The 21-year-old attacking midfielder has become a key figure for Bayern, showcasing his exceptional dribbling skills and creative vision. While primarily known for his playmaking abilities, Musiala’s confidence and composure suggest he could be a reliable option from the spot. His inclusion in the list of potential takers signals Kompany’s growing faith in the young German international.
Musiala’s development is crucial for Bayern’s long-term success. He’s already established himself as a starter, but Kompany and the coaching staff are looking for ways to unlock his full potential. Giving him the responsibility of potentially taking a penalty is a sign of that trust and a vote of confidence in his mental fortitude. It also adds another dimension to Bayern’s attack, making them even more unpredictable for opponents.
The situation also underscores Kane’s importance to the team. The England captain is not only a prolific goalscorer but also the designated penalty taker, a role that adds significantly to his overall contribution. Kane’s consistency from the spot provides a valuable source of goals, and his presence allows Bayern to operate with a clear plan in these crucial moments. However, the club’s willingness to explore alternatives demonstrates their preparedness for any eventuality.
Bayern Munich currently leads the Bundesliga with 63 points, holding an 11-point advantage over Borussia Dortmund with 10 rounds remaining, as of March 3, 2026. They’ve also secured a spot in the DFB-Pokal semi-finals and are competing in the Champions League Round of 16, facing Atalanta. This strong form evokes memories of their treble-winning season in 2020, according to Serge Gnabry, who noted the current team spirit is the best it’s been since then.
Gnabry’s comments highlight the positive atmosphere within the squad, fostered by Kompany’s leadership. The team is demonstrating exceptional cohesion and strength across all competitions, leading to a growing belief that a historic clean sweep of trophies is within reach. The relaxed approach to penalty taking, while seemingly minor, is indicative of a broader sense of confidence and trust that permeates the team.
The club’s attacking prowess is undeniable, having scored 88 goals in the Bundesliga – the league’s most – while conceding only 23. This impressive goal difference reflects a balanced and effective approach to both attack and defense. Kane’s individual form has been exceptional, with 13 goals in seven matches across all competitions as of September 22, 2025, and Gnabry has also contributed with three league goals.
Serge Gnabry recently lauded Kane’s performance, stating, “I think the sky’s the limit for him. The way he scores goals is truly amazing. We’ll see how many he ends up scoring, but we all hope he continues like this.” This sentiment is echoed throughout the squad, who recognize Kane’s exceptional talent and his importance to their ambitions.
Looking ahead, Bayern’s next challenge is a Bundesliga fixture against [Opponent and Date to be confirmed]. The team will be looking to maintain their lead at the top of the table and continue their pursuit of the treble. The question of who will take the next penalty, should Kane be unavailable, remains open, but the club’s flexible approach suggests they are well-prepared for any scenario.
The evolving role of Jamal Musiala, coupled with the team’s overall confidence and Kompany’s leadership, positions Bayern Munich as a formidable force in both domestic and European competitions. The coming months will be crucial as they strive to achieve their ambitious goals and potentially replicate the success of their 2020 treble-winning campaign.
What are your thoughts on Bayern’s penalty taker situation? Share your predictions and opinions in the comments below!
