Rome, Italy – A bold experiment in transparency within Italian football is facing potential extinction. Open VAR, the DAZN program designed to demystify controversial refereeing decisions in Serie A, is under review by the Italian Football Federation (FIGC) and the Association of Italian Referees (AIA), with some officials believing it may be contributing to more confusion than clarity.
Launched three seasons ago, Open VAR aimed to foster a greater understanding of the video assistant referee process by featuring on-air analysis of key incidents, complete with audio from the VAR room and communication between referees on the pitch. However, a growing chorus of concerns – including a perceived increase in referee insecurity and a belief that the program is being exploited – has prompted a serious re-evaluation of its future.
Growing Concerns Over Referee Exposure
The debate surrounding Open VAR comes at a particularly sensitive time for Italian referees, who have faced intense scrutiny this season amid a string of high-profile errors. According to reports in La Stampa, some clubs now view the program as a source of confusion rather than enlightenment, fueling further debate and potentially undermining confidence in officiating.
“A certain atmosphere has developed today and we recognize that; there is an unbearable atmosphere surrounding the management of this delicate phase of the Italian league,” stated FIGC President Gabriele Gravina on March 17, 2026, as reported by Goal.com. Gravina suggested that the commitment to maximum transparency through Open VAR has been “exploited,” and a discussion with the AIA is planned to determine the program’s fate for next season.
The concern isn’t simply about the scrutiny itself, but the potential impact on referee performance. Officials within the AIA reportedly believe the increased exposure and public dissection of their decisions are contributing to insecurity and, paradoxically, an increase in errors. The idea is that the pressure of being publicly analyzed is hindering their ability to produce confident, decisive calls on the field.
A Shift in Perspective
The initial reception to Open VAR was largely positive, with Italy hailed as a pioneer in refereeing transparency. However, the current climate suggests a significant shift in perspective. As one unnamed club director reportedly told La Stampa, “It doesn’t serve any purpose.”
This sentiment is echoed by concerns that the program has inadvertently turned referees into the most publicly criticized element of Italian football. Previously, coaches and players bore the brunt of public scrutiny; now, officials are routinely subjected to intense analysis and debate, often fueled by slow-motion replays and dissected audio recordings.
The FIGC and AIA are now weighing whether the benefits of transparency outweigh the potential drawbacks of increased pressure and insecurity. The decision is complicated by the fact that the program is contracted with DAZN, and any cancellation would likely involve financial implications.
Serie A Too Addressing Protest Conduct
Alongside the Open VAR review, Serie A is also taking steps to address the growing issue of protests and dissent towards referees. The league is developing a new code of conduct aimed at curbing excessive complaints from managers and club officials, with potential sanctions for those who cross the line. This new regulation is expected to be implemented starting next season.
This dual approach – re-evaluating transparency measures and tightening conduct rules – signals a broader effort to address the challenges facing Italian referees and restore a sense of stability to the officiating landscape.
What’s Next for Italian Refereeing?
The future of Open VAR remains uncertain. Whereas a final decision hasn’t been made, the prevailing sentiment within the FIGC and AIA appears to lean towards discontinuation. The coming weeks will be crucial as the two organizations deliberate and weigh the potential consequences of their decision.
Regardless of the outcome, the debate surrounding Open VAR highlights the complex challenges of balancing transparency, accountability, and the well-being of match officials in the modern game. The situation in Italy will undoubtedly be watched closely by other leagues around the world grappling with similar issues.
The next key date to watch is the expected announcement from the FIGC and AIA regarding the future of Open VAR, anticipated before the start of the 2026-2027 Serie A season. Archysport will continue to provide updates as this story develops.
Worth a look
