Fans’ Choice: The Wrong 9?

From Christmas to New Year, fans were able to choose their favorite Bundesliga again. Now the result is clear. These 18 teams would play in the Bundesliga if it were up to you.

Dream Bundesliga: BVB again with the most votes

Over 10,000 fans voted for their dream Bundesliga over the holidays. The selection included all clubs that currently play in the Bundesliga, the 2nd Bundesliga and the 3rd league as well as many former first and second division teams in the Federal Republic of Germany and the GDR. 18 clubs were elected to the desired Bundesliga.

Like last year, Borussia Dortmund again received the most votes. Overall, 93.6 percent of participants voted Borussia into the upper house, another five percent more than in the previous year. In addition to BVB, Eintracht Frankfurt (+7.2 percent), VfB Stuttgart (+5.5) and Hamburger SV (+6.4) were also chosen by over 90 percent of participants.

Bundesliga: Union Berlin and Bayer Leverkusen are new

Overall, the field of participants in the dream Bundesliga consists of eleven current Bundesliga teams, six second division teams and the third division team 1860 Munich.

Compared to the election a year ago, 1. FC Union Berlin and Bayer 04 Leverkusen have made it into the desired Bundesliga. Both clubs already took the first two places in the 2nd Bundesliga last year. Fortuna Düsseldorf and Karlsruher SC are no longer there. Both lost over ten percentage points.

Association Votes in % +/- previous year
Borussia Dortmund 93,6 +5,0
Eintracht Frankfurt 93,2 +7,2
VfB Stuttgart 91,2 +5,5
Hamburger SV 91,1 +6,4
1. FC Cologne 89,1 +9,1
FC Schalke 04 87,2 +6,3
Borussia Mönchengladbach 84,9 +2,3
SV Werder Bremen 84,0 +4,9
FC Bayern Munich 82,0 +7,8
1. FC Kaiserslautern 77,9 +5,1
Hertha BSC 71,6 +7,6
1. FC Nuremberg 63,4 +5,9
TSV 1860 Munich 52,4 +8,4
SC Freiburg 51,7 +1,4
SG Dynamo Dresden 50,8 -0,4
Hannover 96 49,4 +5,4
1. FC Union Berlin 46,8 +9,1
Bayer 04 Leverkusen 43,6 +5,6

2nd Bundesliga: Hansa Rostock in 1st place

The 2nd Bundesliga is made up of places 19 to 36 in the vote for the desired Bundesliga. The field is led by FC Hansa Rostock, which has gained 4.6 percent compared to the previous year. Nevertheless, just under ten points separate FCH from a place in the Bundesliga.

In addition to the “relegated” Düsseldorf and Karlsruhe, there are two other changes compared to last year. FC Rot-Weiß Erfurt and 1. FC Heidenheim are new. Both only made it to the 3rd league last year. The Thuringians already took first place there. SV Waldhof Mannheim and SV Darmstadt 98 are no longer second class.

Association Votes in % +/- previous year
FC Hansa Rostock 34,3 +4,6
VfL Bochum 33,0 -2,2
FC St. Pauli 30,6 -0,6
MSV Duisburg 29,9 +6,0
Karlsruhe SC 29,2 -15,5
Fortuna Düsseldorf 28,3 -17,2
1. FC Magdeburg 22,4 -0,3
Arminia Bielefeld 17,5 +3,3
Red and white food 16,8 +4,4
1. FSV Mainz 05 15,7 -5,4
Alemannia Aachen 14,6 -4,6
1. FC Lokomotive Leipzig 13,6 -2,5
FC Energie Cottbus 12,6 -0,3
Eintracht Braunschweig 11,6 +0,8
FC Augsburg 11,2 +0,3
FC Rot-Weiß Erfurt 8,2 -2,3
1. FC Saarbrücken 8,0 -3,4
1. FC Heidenheim 7,1 -2,0

3rd League: Eight new clubs

The Electoral Palatinate team leads the field of teams in places 37 to 56. The neighboring cities of Halle and Leipzig complete the top 3 of the 3rd league. While Lok Leipzig is in the 2nd Bundesliga, RB Leipzig is ahead of BSG Chemie Leipzig in the 3rd league. In addition to the relegated Mannheim and Darmstadt, Chemnitzer FC, FSV Zwickau, BFC Dynamo, VfL Osnabrück, SV 07 Elversberg and SG Wattenscheid are new participants in the 3rd league.

Last year it wasn’t enough for a place in the top 56. Fortuna Köln, SV Babelsberg, SV Meppen, SC Verl, FC Ingolstadt 04 and Viktoria Köln slipped down.

Association Votes in % +/- previous year
SV Waldhof Mannheim 7,0 -4,8
Hallescher FC 6,9 -2,9
RB Leipzig 6,7 +1,5
VfL Wolfsburg 6,6 -1,9
SC Preußen Münster 6,4 -0,4
Kickers Offenbach 6,2 -4,1
BSG Chemistry Leipzig 6,1 -2,0
SV Darmstadt 98 5,9 -5,7
TSG Hoffenheim 5,5 -3,9
Chemnitzer FC 5,3 +2,5
FC Carl Zeiss Jena 4,9 +0,3
FSV Zwickau 4,8 +2,2
FC Erzgebirge Aue 4,4 -0,8
Stuttgart Kickers 4,2 -0,2
SC Paderborn 4,2 -1,4
Holstein Kiel 3,9 -6,0
BFC Dynamo 3,3 -1,0
VfL Osnabruck 3,1 -0,7
SV Elversberg 3,0 +1,0
SG Wattenscheid 2,7 ±0,0

These teams did not make it into the leagues

Regional league team Rot-Weiß Oberhausen leads the field of teams that missed out on entry into the three leagues. Compared to last year, FC Gütersloh and TSV Havelse are new.

Association Votes in % +/- previous year
Red and white Oberhausen 2,5 +0,4
KSV Hessen Kassel 2,5 -0,9
SV Meppen 2,3 -3,3
Eintracht Trier 2,1 -0,4
SpVgg Fürth 2,0 -0,2
VfB Lübeck 2,0 -0,5
SSV Ulm 1846 2,0 -0,8
SV Babelsberg 03 1,9 -3,6
Westfalia Herne 1,9 +0,2
KFC Uerdingen 05 1,9 -0,1
Wuppertaler SV 1,8 +0,2
Borussia Neunkirchen 1,7 +0,3
SSV Jahn Regensburg 1,6 ±0,0
Tus Koblenz 1,6 -0,3
Würzburger Kickers 1,6 -0,2
VfB Oldenburg 1,6 -0,1
SSV Reutlingen 1,6 -0,3
FC 08 Homburg 1,5 -0,1
SC Fortuna Cologne 1,4 -3,4
FK Pirmasens 1,3 -0,1
SpVgg Bayreuth 1,3 -0,3
Tennis Borussia Berlin 1,3 -0,2
SpVgg Unterhaching 1,2 ±0,0
Wacker Burghausen 1,2 -0,1
1. FC Bocholt 1,1 ±0,0
FC Ingolstadt 04 1,0 -6,9
1. FC Schweinfurt 05 0,9 -0,3
FC Gütersloh 0,9 +0,9
Victoria Cologne 0,9 -7,3
Red White Ahlen 0,9 -0,1
SV Wehen Wiesbaden 0,8 -0,6
TSV Havelse 0,7 +0,7
SV Sandhausen 0,7 -3,7
SC Verl 0,7 -6,9

Next vote on the desired Bundesliga in December

The next vote on the Bundesliga will start next December. At the beginning of the year there will be a vote for the choreo of the year 2025. We wish you a happy new year!

Author: Christian Link
Those: The wrong 9

Marcus Cole

Marcus Cole is a senior football analyst at Archysport with over a decade of experience covering the NFL, college football, and international football leagues. A former NCAA Division I player turned journalist, Marcus brings an insider's understanding of the game to every breakdown. His work focuses on tactical analysis, draft evaluations, and in-depth game previews. When he's not breaking down film, Marcus covers the intersection of football culture and the communities it shapes across America.

Leave a Comment