Belichick NFL Scandal: Hall of Fame Controversy

“I didn’t read it correctly, right? That is IMPOSSIBLE, ATROCIOUS and, frankly, DISRESPECTFUL!”. “Crazy… I don’t even understand how this can be possible.” The first sentence is written LeBron James in your social network X; the second comes out of the thumbs of Patrick Mahomes. They, two of the great bosses of American and world sports, were among the first to speak out on a case that is already branded a scandal. Bill Belichick, the legendary coach who led the New England Patriots to win six Super Bowls and who was the architect of the greatest dynasty in NFL history, will not enter the American Football Hall of Fame this year, at the first opportunity he had. The 73-year-old coach, who now coaches the University of North Carolina, did not receive the necessary 40 votes of the total of 50 members of the panel that elects the members of the Hall of Fame, and will have to wait, at least, one more year to receive this recognition.

Behind him, Belichik has a glorious, legendary career. Before his journey with the Patriots, he already won two rings as defensive coordinator of the New York Giants, and in 2000 he took over as head coach of the New England franchise, a position that he would not let go of until 2023. In those more than two decades, the one from Nashville forged an unmatched career: six Super Bowl wins (1st on the historical list of coaches), nine conference titles and appearances in the final (1st), 31 playoff victories (1st), 302 wins in the regular season (3rd) and 333 games won in total (2nd). Belichik, who led the Patriots to play in the playoffs for 19 seasons (also a record) and who made Tom Brady the greatest quarterback of all time, undoubtedly deserved a place in Canton, Ohio, where the Hall of Fame is located, but This is not how the voters decidedwhose composition is mainly journalists from the cities with franchises in the NFL and fifteen general delegates who hold the position for life.

The reason Belichick was forgotten? As quickly emerged in the American press, The two scandals in which Bill was involved as coach of the Patriots weighed on some voters. One of them was the Spygatein 2007, when they caught New England recording the signals of rival coaches during games, a practice that was prohibited and that had Belichick as its main person in chargesince he had to pay half a million euros and the Patriots lost a first round of the Draft. That’s where it ended, although since then there was a suspicion that the team had been doing it for a long time. Then, in 2015, the Deflategatefor which Tom Brady was accused of asking that the balls that were going to be used in a playoff game be deflated. The quarterback was penalized with four games without playing, and the Patriots had to pay one million euros and lost two draft picks. “Bill Belichick won 100 games and led the Patriots to three Super Bowls.” (winning two) after the Deflategate punishment. His post-scandal resume alone deserves a place in the Pro Football Hall of Fame,” claimed journalist Andrew Siciliano.

According to ESPN, a key role in leaving Belichick out of the Hall of Fame It was played by Bill Polian, who was general manager of the Buffalo Bills and the Indianapolis Colts.two of the Patriots’ great rivals at the beginning of the century and affected by the good work of Belichick. “Bill Polian was a vocal figure in the Hall of Fame deliberations involving Bill Belichick, and the topics Spygate and Deflategate came up among voters during the discussions. He told some voters that he believed Belichick should ‘wait a year’ as penance for Spygate,” the outlet reported. “That is totally and categorically false. I voted for him,” Polian told journalist Matt Verderame hours after this information emerged. However, the version that Polian himself gave to Don Van Natta Jr. was somewhat different. “Polian said he couldn’t remember with 100% certainty if he voted for Belichick.”saying he was 95% sure he voted for the coach. Polian denied telling other voters that Belichick should have a year of penance, although he said he heard that idea floating around, but insisted that he neither agreed nor disagreed with the proposal. “With respect, if you can’t remember who you voted for, you are too senile to vote,” replied Emmanuel Acho, former NFL player and analyst.

Be that as it may, it is not the first case of key figures of the Patriots being removed from the Hall of Fame, since other important figures such as Rodney Harrison, Vince Wilfork, Gino Cappelletti or Adam Vinatieri have not yet been included. Not even Robert Kraft.owner of the franchise since 1994 and who is a candidate to enter this course. In fact, there are more players from the Polian era on the Colts who are in the Hall of Fame (Manning, Harrison, James and Freeney) than from the Patriots who dominated the NFL (Seymour, Law, and Moss). For example, The Dallas Cowboys of the 90s add eight members to the Hall of Fame; the 1980s 49ers have another eight; and the Pittsburgh Steelers of the 70s add 12. The logical thing is that this will change as soon as names like Tom Brady or Rob Gronkowski can be chosenand the rules of the Pro Football Hall of Fame establish that players will be eligible to enter Canton when they have been retired for five years (Brady and Gronk could next year). In the case of coaches, the process is much more agile, since they are eligible when they have been out of the league for a year. In the case of Belichick, who announced his separation from the Patriots on January 11, 2024, this was his first opportunity, and it will not be granted.

“The most scandalous robbery in history!”

“The 10+ people who didn’t vote for Bill Belichick should be exposed. What the hell! This is crazy”was the message that an NFL executive sent to journalist Adam Schefter. “As a member of the Hall of Fame selection board, I cannot believe that Bill Belichick was not included in the first ballot. He had my vote and I will have it next year, assuming we are both in the process,” Dan Pompei, one of the 50 voters, was quick to assure. And the outrage over Belichick’s exclusion was unanimous from the first moment. “I can’t be reading this right. This has to be a knockoff Hall of Fame or something, it can’t be the real NFL Hall of Fame. There isn’t a single world in which Bill Belichick shouldn’t be inducted into the Hall of Fame at his first opportunity,” wrote JJ Watt, legendary defender and now owner of Espanyol.

“Shaking my head,” former Patriots wide receiver Julian Edelman posted. “The biggest stupidity we will see in all of 2026!!!” was the reaction of Devin McCourty, winner of three rings under Belichick’s umbrella. ”This is WRONG… the second most wins of ALL TIME… “More Super Bowls than anyone, an unimaginable number of division championships… a lot of jealous little voters.”said Jimmy Johnson, a coach who won two titles. “No matter what you think of Bill Belichick, he EARNED to be inducted in his first opportunity as a member of the NFL Hall of Fame. 8-time Super Bowl champion. The best NFL coach of all time. For him not to be is RIDICULOUSLY STUPID,” said Robert Griffin III. “Bill Belichick not being inducted into the Hall of Fame on his first ballot is the most outrageous theft in NFL history!” said Aqib Talib.

”Voters must stop remaining anonymous. We need an explanation why Bill Belichick, one of the best coaches of all time, with 8 Super Bowlsis not a first-ballot Hall of Famer… No explanation will be valid, but I need to know. Sorry, man! “It’s crazy!” added Gerald McCoy. “Personal vendettas should not prevent the greatest coach of all time from being elected to the Hall of Fame.” at his first opportunity. Those who didn’t vote for him should be ashamed for not having taken away the emotion. “One of the coolest moments of my career was visiting the Hall of Fame with the team at training camp in 2019 and seeing how much respect Bill had for that place and the history of our sport,” Brian Hoyer posted.

The one who did not make an official statement at the moment was Belichick himself, although ESPN assured that “several sources who spoke with the coach during the weekend “They described Belichick as ‘bewildered’ and ‘disappointed’ by his inability to get the support of at least 80% of the Hall of Fame committee members.”. “Six Super Bowls aren’t enough,” is the question the coach asked when he heard the news. “No one cares more about the history of American football than Bill. Today is a sad day for the league he loves,” is the message journalist Jordan Schultz received from someone close to Belichick. During his time as a coach not everyone liked him and he generated all kinds of opinions, but when it came to recognizing his merits there was absolute unanimity. The injustice will be repaired, without a doubt, and the legendary head coach will enter the Hall of Fame one year, but the fact that he does not do so in his first opportunity has generated a major scandal in the United States, where people cry out to heaven for the ugly man who has probably been the greatest coach in history.

Your opinions matter! Comment on the articles and subscribe for free to our newsletter and to the information alerts in the App or the channel WhatsApp.

Looking to license content? click here