Washington Commanders practice squad quarterback Sam Hartman drew sharp criticism from former NFL players Rob Gronkowski and Julian Edelman after accepting the lead role for season 30 of ABC’s reality dating series, The Bachelor.
The 27-year-old signal-caller was announced as the next franchise lead, with plans to begin filming after the NFL season concludes in January, people.com reported.
Speaking on an episode of The Gronk & Jules Show, Gronkowski and Edelman questioned the timing of Hartman promoting the dating show mid-season. reported that the two New England Patriots alumni reacted with disbelief when discussing Hartman’s appearance on Good Morning America.
The co-hosts noted Hartman’s good “lumberjack” looks before Gronkowski said he was “lab grown to be on The Bachelor,” adding that if someone signs onto social media, every woman is absolutely going bonkers for him.
“Did I see him on Good Morning America promoting this? Like, we’re promoting in the middle of a season? What are we doing?” Julian Edelman said, according to ew.com.
Gronkowski Questions Hartman Roster Status Then Adjusts Criticism
Gronkowski initially questioned whether Hartman remained on the active roster before producer Jack McCarthy confirmed the quarterback plays on the practice squad, ew.com reported. That distinction changed the tone of the critique from the former tight end.
“If you were on the current roster and you accepted this, you deserve a slap in the face,” Rob Gronkowski said, as reported by people.com. “Like, if I was the organization, your priorities aren’t straight, obviously. Like, I would just let you go right on the spot if it was the current roster.”

Once informed of Hartman’s practice squad status, Gronkowski eased his stance. “We’re playing with fumes, but I would let it go,” Gronkowski said, according to ew.com. “But current squad? Yeah, you’re out, because you’re not showing that you’re all in. In the NFL, you’ve gotta be all in.”
He also expressed uncertainty regarding whether Hartman’s head is in the game of football, noting that going on the show as a backup quarterback shows he is not that confident in his future as a quarterback because the series involves a lot of work and filming.
Edelman also weighed in on the financial motivation behind the gig. “He better be getting like a mill! He better be getting a lot of money,” Edelman said, according to ew.com.
Washington Commanders QB Sam Hartman is the new star for Season 30 of 'The Bachelor." Here are his NFL contract details and career highlights. https://t.co/IMyGi1lZmK
Edelman Says Locker Room Would Murder Hartman over Show
The co-hosts debated how past NFL locker rooms would handle a teammate accepting a reality television role. Edelman said that under former standards, a player undertaking such a project would face intense scrutiny from peers, ew.com reported.
Edelman also mentioned Matt James and Tyler Cameron as former football players from Hartman’s college, Wake Forest, who were also cast members of the franchise, joking that Wake Forest is trying to increase female enrollment.
“The locker room would murder him,” Julian Edelman said, according to people.com. “I don’t know how it is now, but with us, oh my God, this guy wouldn’t live.”
One NFL quarterback will soon be passing roses as well as footballs. Sam Hartman, a 27-year-old quarterback for the Washington Commanders, has been named the next star of ABC's "The Bachelor," which returns for its milestone 30th season in March 2027. https://t.co/2ZV26Y0s7H
Gronkowski added that former Patriots coach Bill Belichick would not have tolerated the distraction. “We wouldn’t have been able to make fun of him because Bill would’ve released him by the time he even got back in the locker room,” Gronkowski said, as reported by people.com.
Hartman addressed his teammates’ reactions during his November 13 appearance on Good Morning America. “My teammates, they were giving me some advice on the plane ride back,” Hartman said, according to people.com. “Probably not going to listen to anybody on that … I can’t say [their advice] out loud on national television.” He also added that he is excited but very nervous to do the show.
Hartman signed with Washington as an undrafted free agent in April 2024 following his college career at Notre Dame and Wake Forest, people.com reported. He is in his third year in the league and has not yet appeared in a regular-season game, according to people.com.
ABC confirmed that season 30 of The Bachelor will premiere on March 21, 2027, with Jesse Palmer returning as host, sports.yahoo.com reported.
Keep reading