J.J. McCarthy Leads Giants Past Texans in Overtime Thriller

J.J. McCarthy led the New York Giants to a 27-21 overtime victory against the Houston Texans on October 25, 2026, throwing for 252 yards in his first career start and sending his new team into the bye week at 4-2-1 atop the NFC East.

The New York Giants made a defining bet by trading a 2027 fifth-round pick for J.J. McCarthy after starter Jaxson Dart suffered a season-ending knee injury in Week 2. Less than a month later, that gamble has altered the trajectory of the franchise. After a brief fourth-quarter relief appearance a week prior against the New Orleans Saints where he threw for 243 yards, McCarthy earned his first career start at Reliant Stadium on October 25, 2026. He completed 20 of 28 passes for 252 yards, orchestrating four touchdown drives and lifting the Giants past the Houston Texans in a 27-21 overtime thriller.

J.J. McCarthy Replaces Jameis Winston and Sparking New York’s Offense

Head coach John Harbaugh benched Jameis Winston during the fourth quarter of a loss to the Saints after Winston threw two interceptions. While Winston performed during a stretch following Dart’s injury, the Giants’ offense required a more dynamic spark. Harbaugh named McCarthy the starter for the trip to Houston, a decision that immediately paid dividends.

McCarthy showed the arm talent and poise that made him the No. 10 pick in the 2024 NFL Draft. He became the first Giants quarterback since Eli Manning in 2011 to complete two passes of 40-plus yards in the first quarter alone, hooking up with Malik Nabers and Malachi Fields for explosive gains.

It just wasn’t even a question to me,

John Harbaugh, New York Giants head coach

McCarthy deflected personal praise after the win, crediting his teammates, coaches, and predecessors for getting him up to speed so quickly after arriving via trade from Minnesota.

Football is football. At the end of the day, there’s a lot of similar concepts in every single scheme in the NFL and even going (back) to college.

J.J. McCarthy, New York Giants quarterback

Cam Skattebo and Devin Singletary Deliver in Overtime Against Houston

The ground game provided the necessary complement to McCarthy’s aerial attack, particularly after a sluggish start. Running back Cam Skattebo bounced back after getting no carries the previous week due to a fumbling issue, turning in a performance with 17 carries for 124 yards and a touchdown.

In the extra period, Skattebo broke loose for a 42-yard run that placed the Giants in prime scoring position. On the very next play, Devin Singletary scampered 30 yards into the end zone to win the game in overtime. The dramatic finish sealed a 10.5-point upset for New York, marking the second-largest upset of this NFL season.

First Place in the NFC East Heading Into the Bye Week

The victory sends the Giants into their bye week with a 4-2-1 record, holding sole possession of first place in the NFC East and sitting two and a half games ahead of the Philadelphia Eagles and Dallas Cowboys. Harbaugh’s culture has yielded immediate dividends, already matching last season’s four-win total.

Cornerback Deonte Banks locked down Texans wide receiver Nico Collins, holding the star target to just one catch for 4 yards when matched against him, earning praise from his head coach for tight coverage across the secondary.

The team will rest up during the bye week before returning to action with a road game against the Philadelphia Eagles on November 8.

More on this story: New York Giants Name J.J. McCarthy Starting Quarterback vs. Texans · J.J. McCarthy Sparks Giants Offense in Saints Loss · Caleb Williams Leads Bears to 30-24 Victory Over Patriots

More on John Harbaugh: Najee Harris Released by Giants After Playing Time Complaints · Najee Harris Projected to Lead Giants Backfield in Week 6