Denver Broncos quarterback Bo Nix faces mounting criticism over a conservative start to his season, even as the team sits at 3-2 following a 23-17 road victory over the Los Angeles Chargers under returning play-caller Sean Payton.
Sean Payton Resumes Play-Calling as Denver Edges Los Angeles
Head coach Sean Payton took back play-calling duties from offensive coordinator Davis Webb for the October 11 matchup at SoFi Stadium in Inglewood, California, marking his first game back running the offense. The move failed to spark an immediate offensive revival for the 3-2 Broncos, who finished with just 224 total yards and converted only one of 12 third-down attempts against a heavily depleted Chargers squad led by head coach Jim Harbaugh.
Denver relied heavily on a dominant defensive performance to overcome the offensive struggles. Zach Allen forced a strip-sack of Justin Herbert, and Que Robinson recovered the fumble at the Los Angeles 23-yard line to set up a field goal. Brandon Jones later added an interception, while Ja’Quan McMillian recorded the team’s fifth sack as time expired to seal the 23-17 victory and push Denver’s record to three wins and two losses.
In the aftermath of the contest, observers noted that the offensive output bore little resemblance to a standard high-level professional matchup, with the unit lacking rhythm and generating minimal explosive yardage outside of isolated sequences. Through Week 5, Pro Football Network’s QB Impact Metric graded the signal-caller 28th out of 34 qualified players.
Bo Nix Defends His Play Amid Slumping Passing Metrics
Nix completed 16 of 27 passes for 123 yards, one touchdown, and a lost fumble against the Chargers in his fifth start of the season. Through five games, his 80.8 passer rating ranks 25th among 31 qualified quarterbacks, while his average of 6.0 intended air yards per pass attempt stands as the shallowest in the league according to Next Gen Stats.
Nix pointed to the team’s winning record as the primary metric that matters as the Broncos prepare for a short week. We’re sitting here at 3-2 and having a good start to our season
, Nix said after Tuesday’s workout.
The quarterback’s current numbers reflect a significant drop from his previous campaign, with his completion percentage dipping to 59.9% and his yards per attempt falling to 5.8. Analysts note that these regression figures place him far behind his productive rookie output from 2024.
Dan Orlovsky and Analysts Question Pocket Presence and Footwork
Television analysts and former NFL quarterbacks have raised alarms over Nix’s decision-making and mechanical struggles during the opening month of the season. ESPN analyst Dan Orlovsky broke down game film on The Pat McAfee Show, highlighting how the third-year quarterback handles pressure when his primary option is covered on October 13.
Hall of Famer Kurt Warner similarly reviewed game footage from earlier weeks, noting that Nix has frequently passed up open opportunities downfield instead of letting plays develop. Addressing the external commentary, Nix maintained that he focuses entirely on internal guidance from Payton and quarterbacks coach Logan Kilgore rather than media breakdowns provided by analysts.
Sean Payton’s Message and Contract Questions Shape Denver’s Future
Following the win in Los Angeles, Payton addressed the media regarding his quarterback’s mindset and the broader offensive output on October 12. While declining to assign a confidence grade to Nix during a Monday conference call, Payton shared the direct message he delivered to the former Oregon standout after the game.
“I think, man, we as coaches, like I’ve said to him, I said, ‘Man, you’re the guy we wanted here. Let’s go. You’ve done a ton of things well,’ But I think there’s a lot that goes into that. It’s important that, you know, in that old TV series The Bear, where they just said, ‘Let her rip,’ I want him to make sure that, hey, let her rip.”
The ongoing offensive stagnation has sparked broader debate among media personalities regarding Nix’s long-term future in Denver beyond his rookie contract. Speaking on his show, sports media figure Colin Cowherd urged the organization to exercise caution before considering any extension for their starting quarterback.
“You can’t extend Bo Nix. You let the season play out… His first quarter passer rating is lower than Cam Ward and everybody thinks Cam Ward is a bust.”
Nix is signed through the 2027 season on his standard rookie deal, and Denver holds a fifth-year option for 2028 following his selection in the 2024 NFL Draft. The Broncos return to the field on October 15, 2026, to host the Seattle Seahawks in a Thursday Night Football matchup expected to be played in a rainstorm.
Related reading
