AFL commentators have questioned whether the free agency system is working as intended after another star player nominated a Premiership contender as his preferred new home.
Jeremy Cameron’s decision to move from GWS to Geelong just days before it plays in a grand finale is yet another sign against the idea of the free hand as a balancing instrument.
For the past three years, Cameron has nominated Geelong, Joe Daniher has applied for a move to Brisbane, and Tom Lynch has landed in Richmond – three clubs that made it to the 2020 tentative final weekend.
Witness Fox Footy’s Grand Final Week coverage of Kayo. Stream the latest news and insights through to the first jump, as well as half-time and full-time analysis from the Fox Footy commentary team. New to Kayo? Get your 14-day free trial and start streaming right away>
Big final
I am talking about Fox Footy’s AFL 360, Co-host Gerard Whateley, said the prospect of star players leaving the middle class or clubs underperforming for teams in Premiership competitions is always “an inherent risk.”
“I remember quarreling when the players ‘association said,’ No, this is for the middle-class players to make sure they have a chance. “We told them in a closed room,” This is not going to happen. The top players will move, they will move as they can and it will strengthen the top clubs, “Whateley said.
“I’m not on the front line because everyone has their eyes wide open. It feels to me sometimes like we love trades, except when they don’t really suit Tom Lynch and Jeremy Cameron and then we really get involved with them. “
Giants set for cats
1:00
Of course, not every free hand player is a superstar, and not all of them have moved to top clubs.
Just last year Brandon Ellis switched from Prime Minister Richmond to the Gold Coast wooden spoon. Only two free agents – Tom Lynch and James Frawley (Melbourne to Hawthorn) – moved and have since become Premier Players.
PLAYERS WHO MOVE IN FREE AGENCY (since introduction in AFL)
2012: Troy Chaplin, Brendon Goddard, Brent Moloney, Danyle Pearce, Shannon Byrnes, Chris Ritter, Quinten Lynch, Tom Murphy, Jared Rivers, Clinton Young
2013: Eddie Betts, Nick Dal Santo, Dale Thomas, Dale Thomas, Xavier Ellis, Colin Sylvia, Matt White
2014: James Frawley, Shaun Higgins, James Gwilt, Nick Malceski and Jarrad Waite
2015: Matthew Leuenberger, Scott Selwood, Dawson Simpson and Matt Suckling
2016: Nathan Brown, Ty Vickery, Chris Mayne and Daniel Wells
2017: Steven Motlop, Tom Rockliff and Jackson Trengove
2018: Scott Lycett, Tom Lynch, Reece Conca, Luke Dahlhaus and Alex Fasolo
2019: Brandon Ellis, Grant Birchall, Adam Tomlinson and Cam Ellis-Yolmen
Note: Does not include free agents that have been traded, such as B. Patrick Dangerfield
Tom Lynch’s second grand final in two years will be in Richmond on Saturday after moving from Gold Coast. (Photo by Quinn Rooney / Getty Images)Source: Getty Images
“If you come from the player’s point of view, it absolutely works because it gives you the freedom to go to a top club,” St. Kilda’s Nick Riewoldt said of Fox Footy’s On the couch.
“But I’m not sure if the AFL thought this would happen if they brought it in.”
Brownlow medalist Gerard Healy added, “This has always been the case.
“When the free agency stepped in and they were illegally authorized to overpay, it was suddenly ‘OK, do you really want to stay at this football club?’ And the temptation to go home and south is great. “
With the Giants, the problem was the inability to keep all of their stars – which was essentially impossible given that many talented players in the same age group were joining the club at the same time.
However, their location outside of a natural AFL talent hotspot in Sydney’s west has also resulted in them having to pay many players extra costs not to go home.
Add in the extra cost of living in Sydney that the often malicious COLA payments should help with, and there are situations where players like Cameron don’t get paid for what they think is worth.
Fox Sports Sportmail gets the latest AFL news, highlights and analysis straight to your inbox. Join Now!
“Philosophically, I always thought that the clubs up north had to pay too much to see what the Brisbane Lions had been doing for the past two or three years,” said great Lions Jonathan Brown On the couch.
“You have your salary cap okay. You’re not paying too much now. Culturally they’re in a really good place, and now players want to play there for fair money or maybe a little less.
“Maybe they (the giants) are making this shift. The Lions drew the line in the sand and said, no, we’re sick of player managers coming up to us and saying we want 20 percent more than you would get for fair value at a club in Melbourne, for example. “
While empowering players is positive, it’s not that some clubs are disadvantaged to begin with.
Nick Dal Santo, who joined the club as one of the earliest free agents in 2013 when he left St. Kilda to retire in North Melbourne, also believes the system is not working as originally intended.
“I’m not sure the AFL actually planned the free agency to play,” Dal Santo told Fox Sports News. AFL Tonight.
“Obviously we’ve spent a lot of time overseas and seen other sports, especially in America. But AFL has something different and I think Australian sport on a larger scale isn’t always about the money, it’s also about winning and being part of a Premiership team and a Premiership club. That is what is so appealing about cats.
“It’s not uncommon for players to move to another club, maybe outside the top few percent, and actually take less money to be at a more successful club. We saw Tom Lynch a few years ago – and we’ve seen how that worked out – and it could possibly be the same if last year’s Coleman Medalist works with this year’s Coleman Medalist. It’s just crazy where the system is right now. “
Neale wins the Brownlow Medal
1:56
Dal Santo said it was either a matter of strong clubs getting stronger or not being able to fall off so quickly.
“It makes it really difficult for the club to get (the player) going,” he said.
“So when it comes to compensation, when it comes to trades on the way back, that compensation takes a while. It’s just very difficult to bring them together. When you talk about American sports, like NBA, all you need is two or three good players and this franchise looks completely different. That doesn’t fit the AFL, it’s just so different and much more complex to put together a winning team. “
AFL acts in 2020: Free agency, problems, Jeremy Cameron to Geelong, system broken, best players joining the best clubs, news
AFL commentators have questioned whether the free agency system is working as intended after another star player nominated a Premiership contender as his preferred new home.
Jeremy Cameron’s decision to move from GWS to Geelong just days before it plays in a grand finale is yet another sign against the idea of the free hand as a balancing instrument.
For the past three years, Cameron has nominated Geelong, Joe Daniher has applied for a move to Brisbane, and Tom Lynch has landed in Richmond – three clubs that made it to the 2020 tentative final weekend.
Witness Fox Footy’s Grand Final Week coverage of Kayo. Stream the latest news and insights through to the first jump, as well as half-time and full-time analysis from the Fox Footy commentary team. New to Kayo? Get your 14-day free trial and start streaming right away>
I am talking about Fox Footy’s AFL 360, Co-host Gerard Whateley, said the prospect of star players leaving the middle class or clubs underperforming for teams in Premiership competitions is always “an inherent risk.”
“I remember quarreling when the players ‘association said,’ No, this is for the middle-class players to make sure they have a chance. “We told them in a closed room,” This is not going to happen. The top players will move, they will move as they can and it will strengthen the top clubs, “Whateley said.
“I’m not on the front line because everyone has their eyes wide open. It feels to me sometimes like we love trades, except when they don’t really suit Tom Lynch and Jeremy Cameron and then we really get involved with them. “
Giants set for cats
1:00
Of course, not every free hand player is a superstar, and not all of them have moved to top clubs.
Just last year Brandon Ellis switched from Prime Minister Richmond to the Gold Coast wooden spoon. Only two free agents – Tom Lynch and James Frawley (Melbourne to Hawthorn) – moved and have since become Premier Players.
PLAYERS WHO MOVE IN FREE AGENCY (since introduction in AFL)
2012: Troy Chaplin, Brendon Goddard, Brent Moloney, Danyle Pearce, Shannon Byrnes, Chris Ritter, Quinten Lynch, Tom Murphy, Jared Rivers, Clinton Young
2013: Eddie Betts, Nick Dal Santo, Dale Thomas, Dale Thomas, Xavier Ellis, Colin Sylvia, Matt White
2014: James Frawley, Shaun Higgins, James Gwilt, Nick Malceski and Jarrad Waite
2015: Matthew Leuenberger, Scott Selwood, Dawson Simpson and Matt Suckling
2016: Nathan Brown, Ty Vickery, Chris Mayne and Daniel Wells
2017: Steven Motlop, Tom Rockliff and Jackson Trengove
2018: Scott Lycett, Tom Lynch, Reece Conca, Luke Dahlhaus and Alex Fasolo
2019: Brandon Ellis, Grant Birchall, Adam Tomlinson and Cam Ellis-Yolmen
Note: Does not include free agents that have been traded, such as B. Patrick Dangerfield
“If you come from the player’s point of view, it absolutely works because it gives you the freedom to go to a top club,” St. Kilda’s Nick Riewoldt said of Fox Footy’s On the couch.
“But I’m not sure if the AFL thought this would happen if they brought it in.”
Brownlow medalist Gerard Healy added, “This has always been the case.
“When the free agency stepped in and they were illegally authorized to overpay, it was suddenly ‘OK, do you really want to stay at this football club?’ And the temptation to go home and south is great. “
With the Giants, the problem was the inability to keep all of their stars – which was essentially impossible given that many talented players in the same age group were joining the club at the same time.
However, their location outside of a natural AFL talent hotspot in Sydney’s west has also resulted in them having to pay many players extra costs not to go home.
Add in the extra cost of living in Sydney that the often malicious COLA payments should help with, and there are situations where players like Cameron don’t get paid for what they think is worth.
Fox Sports Sportmail gets the latest AFL news, highlights and analysis straight to your inbox. Join Now!
“Philosophically, I always thought that the clubs up north had to pay too much to see what the Brisbane Lions had been doing for the past two or three years,” said great Lions Jonathan Brown On the couch.
“You have your salary cap okay. You’re not paying too much now. Culturally they’re in a really good place, and now players want to play there for fair money or maybe a little less.
“Maybe they (the giants) are making this shift. The Lions drew the line in the sand and said, no, we’re sick of player managers coming up to us and saying we want 20 percent more than you would get for fair value at a club in Melbourne, for example. “
While empowering players is positive, it’s not that some clubs are disadvantaged to begin with.
Nick Dal Santo, who joined the club as one of the earliest free agents in 2013 when he left St. Kilda to retire in North Melbourne, also believes the system is not working as originally intended.
“I’m not sure the AFL actually planned the free agency to play,” Dal Santo told Fox Sports News. AFL Tonight.
“Obviously we’ve spent a lot of time overseas and seen other sports, especially in America. But AFL has something different and I think Australian sport on a larger scale isn’t always about the money, it’s also about winning and being part of a Premiership team and a Premiership club. That is what is so appealing about cats.
“It’s not uncommon for players to move to another club, maybe outside the top few percent, and actually take less money to be at a more successful club. We saw Tom Lynch a few years ago – and we’ve seen how that worked out – and it could possibly be the same if last year’s Coleman Medalist works with this year’s Coleman Medalist. It’s just crazy where the system is right now. “
Neale wins the Brownlow Medal
1:56
Dal Santo said it was either a matter of strong clubs getting stronger or not being able to fall off so quickly.
“It makes it really difficult for the club to get (the player) going,” he said.
“So when it comes to compensation, when it comes to trades on the way back, that compensation takes a while. It’s just very difficult to bring them together. When you talk about American sports, like NBA, all you need is two or three good players and this franchise looks completely different. That doesn’t fit the AFL, it’s just so different and much more complex to put together a winning team. “
.
Share this:
Related
Comments
Trending
Florida State Football Stars Await NFL Fate: Where Will They Land in Draft?
DFL constitutional complaint: Who has to pay? – Karlsruhe negotiates costs for high-risk games – video
Madrid Masters: Nadal debuted with a resounding victory | The former Spanish number one won 6-1 and 6-0 against the American Darwin Blanch, 16 years old
Nadal Dominates 16-Year-Old in Madrid Opener
Tags